Brent Harvey???

Madmax75 · August 25, 2011, 12:19:10 PM

Thinking of bringing in Boomer this week but concerned over the tagging job C JOnes has done in the past on him. I cant see any better options though at 430 k or less. This is what I have left if I trade Broughton for Enright and keep Gibbs which seems to be the best move. Otherwise I could trade GIbbs for Enright and then get any forward up to 536k. What do you think. Help please. I have 2 trades left and will use them this week as I have backup premiums in forwards and mids with the Petrie switch for the ruck. If I trade pav for a forward then I would have to start Puolpolo.

charliesheen · August 25, 2011, 12:24:02 PM

Can you post rest of team?

Do your options open up if you go Broughton > Birchall, Pavlich > PREMIUM FORWARD?

elite · August 25, 2011, 12:25:57 PM

I am also looking at Harvey to be traded in this round.
I am also worried about Harvey copping the Jones tag as he has done in the past and he usually does it pretty well unless he tags Wells or Swallow instead this time. I think Ringo or Charliesheen posted up some stats on his past match where he got tagged by Jones.

Madmax75 · August 25, 2011, 12:29:53 PM

Team is :

(Differences I have highlighted and his differences below again)
B Goddard Puopolo Deledio Fisher Broughton Birchall Adcock (Bachelor LIsle Gibbs )
C Swan Pendles Ablett Boyd Moloney S Mitchell (Bartel Bewick Mullet)
R Cox Mumford (Thompson J tippet)
F Buddy Rioli Goodes N roo Cloke Petrie Okeefe (Mzungu Pav C Richo)

His differences: R Murphy Heppel Otten (or Gibbs replacement) Hodge Montagna Fyfe J Roo Lecras

charliesheen · August 25, 2011, 12:37:11 PM

i think enright and harvey are solid options.

mind you against Freo, he was probably on target for a 140+ score until he did some uncharacteristic mistakes @ goal.

penskifile · August 25, 2011, 01:02:00 PM

If broughton is out, then pull the trigger on Enright. Why are you looking at the boomer trade though? Is it to cover Petrie if Cox is out? If so, then get Boomer, otherwise i would just do the 1 trade and get Enright.

charliesheen · August 25, 2011, 01:03:09 PM

Quote from: penskifile on August 25, 2011, 01:02:00 PM
If broughton is out, then pull the trigger on Enright. Why are you looking at the boomer trade though? Is it to cover Petrie if Cox is out? If so, then get Boomer, otherwise i would just do the 1 trade and get Enright.

didn't notice that. quite a good point actually...

maybe he doens't want to start Nroo lol!

Madmax75 · August 25, 2011, 04:11:54 PM

So what do you recommend then trade Gibbs for suckling so I don't have to start Puopolo? Gibbs would be a handy in if I can get thru this weeks PF. Is there anywhere I can strengthen the team other than bringing in Enright that is worth using the last trade I have ? Pav is the only one worth enough to prob trade.