Last Trade Puopolo for Enright, Pav for S Mitchell or Gibbs for Bock

[Dave2008]

I have one trade left and 120k. Which option above do you think or is there a better one?
Pros Cons:

1. Bring in Enright (or any defender up to 455,900) for Puopolo. Pros keep Gibbs finish backline Cons start Mzungu and I Smith the rest being premiums and Pederson is only backup in defence.
(Defenders I already have are: Goddard Gibbs Deledio Fisher Adcock Suckling Grundy (Pederson Puopolo Lisle)

2. Bring in S Mitchell for Pav. Pros Finsh Mids, keep Gibbs. Cons start Pederson or Puoplo in defence and Mzungu or I Smith in forwards.


3. Bring in Gibbs for Bock or any defender. Pros Able to get any defender and finish defence. Cons loose Gibbs for possible GF start I Smith and Mzungu.

This is assuming Cox is out so I have to swing Petrie into Ruck.

[Ringo]

Without seeing whole team I would wait till team announcements and see whether you have to use last trade. I would niot if confident of winning

backs are well covered as you can start Pup or Pedersen for Gibbs.

Not sure of Mids or Forwards but if need a trade i would be trading Pav as he probably wont play again.

[Madmax75]

Ringo team is:

Goddard Gibbs Deledio Fisher Adcock Suckling Grundy (Puopolo Pederson Lisle)
Swan Pendels Ablett Del Santo Cross Pavlich (Krakouer I SmithPrestia)
Mumford Cox (J Tippet Moran)
Franklin Goodes Okeefe Fyfe T Cloke Petrie N Roo (Mzungu Callinan Howe)

I think its going to be a tough match up in the prelim. My opponent the following differences and mine are in bold above:

Boyd Montagna McEvoy Rioli Bock Heppel Chapman J Roo

[charliesheen]

So basically

Enright (100) - backs
Mzungu (90) - mids
i.smith (90) - fwd
280?

vs

Puopolo/Pederson (60) - backs
Mitchell (125) - mids
i. smith (90) - fwd
275?

vs

Bock (110) - backs
Mzungu (90)- mids
I.Smith (90) - fwd
290?

I think option 2 might be best for the next round, but may be weaker than option 1 and 3 for this round.  Really depends how Mitchell handles the picken tag.  I think he might be good for about 120. 

Then you have to take into account how pedo/puopolo will do against Saints.  I think Mzungu/I.Smith have a higher ceiling than pedo this week.

[plugz19]

pav-> dale thomas

[charliesheen]

pav-> dale thomas

The question is whether gaining a premium mid (whether it be dale thomas/mitchell/whatever), will off set the hit you may take from playing puopolo/pedo this WEEK.

its hard to say.  pedo's form has been encouraging but I'm not sure how he will go against the Saints.  puopolo is just as unpredictable.

[Ringo]

This is a hard one need to decide which trade gives you the better return and negates any advantage.

Another alternative to consider but always go with gut feel is Boomer harvey playing St Kilda and Richmong who he scored 92 and 125 in previous rounds and with North fighting for the eight will not be rested