The Who to start Thread...

[ossie85]

1 trade left i`m thinking of going pav to cloke i have enough cash to get anyone except Davis
current forwards
Stevie.J,Goodes,Franklin,Rioli,N.Roo,Mzungu,Pav
Karnezis,Dalhaus,Sylvia(who i am happy to bench for the year and paly Mzungu)

do i stick with Lobbe on the field or put Smith back on?

Out of these which 3 should be on the field Martin,Broughton,Lower and puopolo?

Smith over Lobbe..... and bench Poup

[LF]

why has this been moved  to the who to start thread today when i posted this yesterday i`m asking for trade help not just who to start.

[dmac07]

Mine moved here too, now have no poll and no answers.... Why?

[roo boys!]

Who to start, Puopolo or Duffield?

[ossie85]

Who to start, Puopolo or Duffield?

Pup.


Sorry luv footy, it looked to me you had made your decision about the trade, my bad.

And dmac07, you got an answer.

[MontyJnr]

Merging all these 'who to start' threads is such a turn off and just confusing. I just want to see a poll between mzungu and nick riewoldt and maybe some detailed discussion. This mess of a thread doesn't allow that.

[LF]

Who to start, Puopolo or Duffield?

Pup.


Sorry luv footy, it looked to me you had made your decision about the trade, my bad.

And dmac07, you got an answer.

thats ok i have`nt yet i`m still trying to finish my dt team lol.

[ossie85]

Merging all these 'who to start' threads is such a turn off and just confusing. I just want to see a poll between mzungu and nick riewoldt and maybe some detailed discussion. This mess of a thread doesn't allow that.

Nobody replies in depth to these threads... more than once anyway. Mzungu is mentioned in THOUSANDS of threads every week.

Plus most (not all) don't offer any of there own opinions.... just give a choice

.... plus, I don't understand these threads in general. Wouldn't it be simpler just to give your username and password on these forums if you're gonna let people make the decision for you.

[charliesheen]

Who to start, Puopolo or Duffield?

Gonna say Duff.  This could blow up in your face, or you could look at a very good score.

Quietly confident this week, with how the Freo team is lining up. 

[wardie]

Merging all these 'who to start' threads is such a turn off and just confusing. I just want to see a poll between mzungu and nick riewoldt and maybe some detailed discussion. This mess of a thread doesn't allow that.

+1 stop merging these threads together. once you do they all get lost along with the polls

dont even know where mine is now :-

[ossie85]

With no trades left i am forced to play one of these 2 in the forwards (the other will be back emergency)

McKERNAN has looked ok since Bicks took over but TALIA i feel as more scoring potential.

Agree, Talia... close though

And you'll notice that nobody was replying to that thread anyway.

That's the problem with these who to start threads... they are always 2-3 posts long, often asking the same thing. McKernan v Talia? Isn't half the fun guessing yourself!

[wyldie36]

I am fielding Mzungu and need to decide which Roo to bench.

any advice ? cheers

[CFC 1979]

J

[Runnin Scared]

Going out shortly, who to put on the bench

[CFC 1979]

had faith in ROO all year.

It's time for the big one