The Who to start Thread...

[twinkle]

I am playing Roo over Petrie. Saints a shut down side and likley low scoring game - Petrie might not see much of the ball. Mind you Roo not 100%...

[J Pot]

Have to leave out 1 of Didak, Mzungu or Higgins. Higgins is reasonably solid, Mzungu has been in pretty good form and Didak is comming off a 30 possi game, and has huge upside. Thoughts???

[thatguy]

its bloody difficult. last time they played Petrie got killed, but the Roos didnt exactly look after the dish.

also remember he did score 100 against the cats at skilled on a day they got thumped.

if i had to choose, i would prob lean towards petrie, but i moved him to my second ruck spot anyway so i have to play both!

[thatguy]

really is a pretty simple decision i would have thought. rest the leading scorer? hmmm.

[ossie85]

With no trades left i am forced to play one of these 2 in the forwards (the other will be back emergency)

McKERNAN has looked ok since Bicks took over but TALIA i feel as more scoring potential.

Agree, Talia... close though

[nath01]

I really dont trust big Nick any more, but im also not sure how Mzungu will go against the Pies

Any thoughts would be appreciated

Thanks

[charliesheen]

Mzungu is playing as a mid now.  will have plenty of opportunity to score.

NROO averages about 140+ against the Roo but is in terrible form.  Kicks 2 goals, then fades.

If you don't think he will fade after half time, could be a good option.

Basically it comes down to current form vs historical data.  Which do you prefer?

[tonesturt]

Who should I leave out. Either Montagna, I Smith or Didak

[tor01doc]

Basically, can we trust Didak?

[charliesheen]

its also a matter of guys like fasolo taking the points from didak in front of goals.  pies 2011 is much different than pies 2010.

personally I would just base my decision on current form, and take out all the speculation and what if's from the equation.

[charliesheen]

Who should I leave out. Either Montagna, I Smith or Didak

gotta back tags. 

[tor01doc]

2 whole votes from 40 views locked at 1 apiece is not all that helpful!

[ossie85]

2 whole votes from 40 views locked at 1 apiece is not all that helpful!

This questions been asked a squillion times in the last 2 months or so....

[felsty]

wanna put tendai on but maybe issac as well.. tell me what you think

[LF]

bump