The Who to start Thread...

[Madmax75]

I am leaning towards starting Moloney ahead of Bartel as he plays against GC whereas Syd can lock down games even though it is at SS. What do you think?

[charliesheen]

this is actually a tough question

with Sylvia out I wonder who is gonna grab all the points now. 

If the Jamar/Moloney combo get back to where it was @ the start of the year, could be some big points.

[Luigi197]

thats a close one.

BARTEL:
v Sydney at Skilled.
Past 5 at Skilled: 86, 138, 144, 112, 159
r4 v Sydney at SCG: 75.

MOLONEY:
v Gold Coast at MCG
Past 5 at MCG: 90, 100, 82, 117, 132.
r4 v Gold Coast at Gabba: 152

Moloney because Melbourne and GCS have no chance of finals. A Shoot-out.

[charliesheen]

bartel can be one hell of a frustrating ride lol.

get some cheap ball some!

[GoLions]

after 2 sub 100 scores i reckon bartels due for a 120+ game. i wouldnt be so sure that moloneys going to do well. dees in horrible form so i think there wont be many stand out scores in that game except for gaj

[charliesheen]

after 2 sub 100 scores i reckon bartels due for a 120+ game. i wouldnt be so sure that moloneys going to do well. dees in horrible form so i think there wont be many stand out scores in that game except for gaj

Bartel's scores is dependent on his roles which almost changes on a week by week basis.  Sometimes he plays off HBF, sometimes in the guts, sometimes more up forward, sometimes a mix.

The problem with Bartel is that he really needs to pull something out of the hat, like kick goals, to get a decent SC now days.

Saying that, Moloney is not much better, but it is against Gold Coast at the MCG too.

[Torress]

its a 50/50
i always like to pick the horse who has more class. so definately bartel for me. moloney can go missing.
its at skilled stadium.. gaj (did whilst a cat) and bartel score big against the swans traditionally.
so bartel is playing on a track where the cats are advantaged, proven form against opposition, and coming off a week layoff.. spells a good ton for me.
mind you dees vs the GC?? that makes it hard! although i've made players captain against GC like boyd ages ago expecting a big one but the scores were more evenly spread?? you find more players from the team playing the GC beats their direct opponent; resulting in a more even spread.. that mckensie has been really good this year with clearances from the dees. he could have a bigger one, so could scully (if plays) trengrove as well. i think the outside players against the gc are the ones who should do well. rischetelli and gaj will do a good job in and under. moloney mostly an inside type of player?

i say lock in bartel bascially!

[charliesheen]

I'm gonna go Moloney.

Moloney scored 152 against GCS in Round 4.  GCS are the number 1 side in giving away the most fantasy captaincy points in the competition.  The game is also at the MCG, and there were a lot of encouraging signs last week.

The way I see it, Bartel could potentially get another showerty role which is going to impact his scores.

At least you know what your going to get with Moloney.  Think he has a point to prove.

[hazzq]

All have had pretty decent last 3 weeks all averaging 90+
Im looking for advice which 2 to pick this week.

Any suggestions will be Appreciated

[charliesheen]

Gee tough one to split

Last 5 rounds

Hale: 96.60
Mzungu: 96.00
I.Smith: 81.00 take out the game as sub it is 98.75

I'm gonna go Hale and I.Smith.  Better off flipping a coin lol!

[CFC 1979]

wait for teams

smith and hale both had injuries last week

Gu will be our saviour

[coolfugitiv0]

wait for teams

smith and hale both had injuries last week

Gu will be our saviour

Please tell me your not serious :/
I need both Smith and Gu to play or I cop a donut. FMSC.

[PowerToWin]

Mzungu for sure, especially with outs the Dockers have this week.

Id go Hale also. I have him, I like him.

[LF]

1 trade left i`m thinking of going pav to cloke i have enough cash to get anyone except Davis
current forwards
Stevie.J,Goodes,Franklin,Rioli,N.Roo,Mzungu,Pav
Karnezis,Dalhaus,Sylvia(who i am happy to bench for the year and paly Mzungu)

do i stick with Lobbe on the field or put Smith back on?

Out of these which 3 should be on the field Martin,Broughton,Lower and puopolo?

[n186]

Thought ill get things rolling...

For me J riewoldt in fwd line, or Z smith in ruck, with Petrie up forward or J riewoldt up fwd and Petrie ruck with Z Smith on bench.. thinking the 2nd option with no other Ruckman for GC.