Dreadful Defenders

[Dizzy]

Planning to get rid of Gibbs, no decent defenders to get, any ideas? (Broughton on black list)

[thatguy]

Planning to get rid of Gibbs, no decent defenders to get, any ideas? (Broughton on black list)

prob helps mate if you post the rest of your backline!

[plugz19]

exactly why people still have stanley/heppel on their fields! doing as well as so called 'premiums'

[SydneyRox]

I am not sure trading Gibbs is the best idea!! There is no one you could go to with confidence....

I am tossing up the same, have Murphy and Gibbs, with two trades, but think I may hang onto them and test my luck

[thanme]

Yeah I've got Gibbs and Scotland, and was planning on dropping 1, but I dunno :P The way some other defenders are playing, it might be worth squeezing through this round with 2 benchies. Especially now Pav is gone and Sylvia may go bye byes.

[Dizzy]

my defence is:

Gibbs, Goddard, Dids, Heppell, Fisher, Suckling and Enright (Duigan, Toy, Karmichael) weak bench

Birchall could be one, but seems to have gone back to his 70s

[fertalong]

I also have gibbs and scotland and was thinking I would trade mzungu/pav/sylvia to gram to cover to cover one and stanley for the other. Then use gram in my back line instead of adcock in r24.

Good idea or bad?

[PowerBug]

I also have gibbs and scotland and was thinking I would trade mzungu/pav/sylvia to gram to cover to cover one and stanley for the other. Then use gram in my back line instead of adcock in r24.

Good idea or bad?

I like Gram, good player who can score big against North and Carlton.

Dizzy, did you have Danny Stanley at the stat? Too bad if you did, too bad if you didn't :P

[Dizzy]

not a very good idea, check for Pav's injury, but other wise dont do it PS PowerBug Karmichael is a legend v

[PowerBug]

not a very good idea, check for Pav's injury, but other wise dont do it PS PowerBug Karmichael is a legend v

Legend????

[Dizzy]

went past the half century this week, gonna be superstar plus he could K.O. Danny Stanley anyday

[PowerBug]

went past the half century this week, gonna be superstar plus he could K.O. Danny Stanley anyday

Could had an extra 700 points if you had Stanley over Hunt.

[Dizzy]

you would have 700 points less if you had K. Hunt, but you would have had a guy called Karmichael

[PowerBug]

you would have 700 points less if you had K. Hunt, but you would have had a guy called Karmichael

So what? You'd rather a better name than 700+ points?

[LF]

i was considering trading out scotland and benching gibbs for the week but with sylvia,pav and n.roo in doubt i may just have to play puopolo and pederson instead.especially if pav and sylvia are gone for the year