Everyone captain in the preliminary????

[roo boys!]

Gazza vs Swan.. think I'll go Gazza.

[Samm79]

Swan v Ablett, both love a big ground in PS and the MCG, Swan for me, Ablett's 19 in round 16 wearing the captains cape is probably the deciding factor... That round lost me over 8,000 spots!

[roo boys!]

I brought him in that week - luckily I wasn't home so couldn't make him captain like planned, so didn't miss out too much :)

[JB0016]

Can't decide between those 2.

Risk and reward? or play it safe? Due to me having so many outs, I'm underdog in all my league prelims, is it worth picking Buddy as a smokey?

[gpdemons]

I know it's tempting to go Buddy, it was tempting against the suns too, but that failed terribly.. GAJ in my opinion will go crazy and get at least 40 touches barring injury or anything silly, I think it would be wise to go the safe option in GAJ. The only kinda risk I would take if I were you would be going a proven captain player like a Swan, Boyd or one of those types. Hope that helps!

[roo boys!]

Never know what you are going to get with Buddy. In a prelim, it's do or die, play it safe and go Gazza.

[Turbo]

If you're a fair way behind then maybe go the risky option of Buddy and hope he kicks 10 and clocks up 200.  If it's pretty close then back your side and go with Gaz.

[FonFatty]

No love for Joelwood?
You would think in a contested game with lots of stoppages the Geelong champ could knock up a very big ton.. Especially with the game being played at skilled...
I dont think Ablett will go big this week simply because the dees have 2 handy types that can shut down key players, that being Bartram and Mackenzie, they will rotate on him and negate his influence on the game..
As for Swan, I think he will go big this week, around the 150-170 mark..
What about Buddy? He could kick his first bag of 10 tomorrow and if he does go that high, he will hit a double century guaranteed..

[oconnell]

big decision i have to make so plzz vote!!!

[roo boys!]

I'm going with Gazza. Niether should really let you down I don't think.

[dmac07]

Pretty happy with Swan C at half time :)

[North Melbournes Finest]

I asked 4 billion people today who I should make Captain out of the two, ended up going with GAJ, it shouldn't make too much difference if they score within about 15-20 of each other, you'll only lose 10 points or so.

[coolfugitiv0]

Swan not quite 150.
That was Pendles haha.

Come on GAJ!

[all about winning]

Swan 124. ..
Gaj 160+.....