Aaron Mullett to debut this week!

[AFEV]

You can't argue that Goldy and Swallow haven't had amazing seasons though...

Oh no I don't doubt that. But past achievements vs. potential for young players...Surely potential (if they have already shown it at AFL level) wins out?

Of course, but both of them are still young with a lot more left to achieve in their careers.

But...Hurley is better :P

PS Where did the dog gif go D:

[bomberboy0618]

You can't argue that Goldy and Swallow haven't had amazing seasons though...

Oh no I don't doubt that. But past achievements vs. potential for young players...Surely potential (if they have already shown it at AFL level) wins out?

Of course, but both of them are still young with a lot more left to achieve in their careers.

But...Hurley is better :P

PS Where did the dog gif go D:

Hurley is, and will be, a beast. Even when we are getting owned, beasting it up.
Potential wins out for young players IMO.

[roo boys!]

You can't argue that Goldy and Swallow haven't had amazing seasons though...

Oh no I don't doubt that. But past achievements vs. potential for young players...Surely potential (if they have already shown it at AFL level) wins out?

Of course, but both of them are still young with a lot more left to achieve in their careers.

But...Hurley is better :P

PS Where did the dog gif go D:

Hurley is, and will be, a beast. Even when we are getting owned, beasting it up.
Potential wins out for young players IMO.

So Swallow has no potential? ::)

[Master Q]

He's no Judd  ;)

[roo boys!]

He's no Judd  ;)

No-one (apart from Judd :P) is a Judd ::) :P

[AFEV]

He's no Judd  ;)

No-one (apart from Judd :P) is a Judd ::) :P

Which Judd are you referring to? :P

[bomberboy0618]

He's no Judd  ;)

No-one (apart from Judd :P) is a Judd ::) :P

O.Judd is technically a Judd :P.

[roo boys!]

He's no Judd  ;)

No-one (apart from Judd :P) is a Judd ::) :P

Which Judd are you referring to? :P

Donald.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Judd

[North Melbournes Finest]

On a serious note Judd will go down as a top 5 player in history and quite likely top 3. He'll win 4-5 Brownlow medals, he's a flowering jet.

[AFEV]

On a serious note Judd will go down as a top 5 player in history and quite likely top 3. He'll win 4-5 Brownlow medals, he's a flowering jet.

I generally see Haydn Bunton as the best ever but of course I never actually saw him. Reading about him though...He sounds unbelievable.

[Master Q]

On a serious note Judd will go down as a top 5 player in history and quite likely top 3. He'll win 4-5 Brownlow medals, he's a flowering jet.

I generally see Haydn Bunton as the best ever but of course I never actually saw him. Reading about him though...He sounds unbelievable.

Better than Whitnall?  :P

[hawk_88]

Locked the thread!

I like to give some leeway but this is well and truly off-topic.


On a side note, things got too heated in this debate. Don't attack the man, attack the topic and be prepared to agree to disagree.