Who to Start?

Started by wardie, August 15, 2011, 12:43:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who do i bench out of these options?

J Riewoldt (vs MELB)
N Riewoldt (vs SYD)
T Mzungu (vs KAN)
C Sylvia vs (RICH)
D Petrie (vs FRE)

charliesheen

I think Poo will need to play very very tightly on Garlett/Betts.  Bit nervous about him this week.

Sully

Having a major dilemma picking between these three guys to fill one spot. Smith and Mzungu's form has been good in recent weeks but I have the Nick Lower factor in the back of my mind of putting faith in rookies over proven campaigners (even if that proven campaigner's form has been shisen!) Any advice appreciated!

Cheers

charliesheen

Quote from: Sully on August 16, 2011, 04:09:47 PM
Having a major dilemma picking between these three guys to fill one spot. Smith and Mzungu's form has been good in recent weeks but I have the Nick Lower factor in the back of my mind of putting faith in rookies over proven campaigners (even if that proven campaigner's form has been shisen!) Any advice appreciated!

Cheers

just bench nick lower.  do you have any other rookies in the back you can play?

Jay


Jay

who to start as D7 for rnd 22

Puopolo v carlon
Lower v n.m

Cheers

Mark

Lower bad score last week and have North at Edihad

Puopolo good score last week and have Carlton at Edihad

Please don't just read, leave a comment and help a guy out :)

ossie85


Lower for me! He has a history of bouncing back hard!

charliesheen

Just curious has Nick Lower ever been subbed off outside of PS?

PICCOLLO

Harvey has been quoted as saying players may get dropped.  If lower listed low on bench, he may be the sub this week.  (mundy prob will be sub though) Having said that, i think he is good for at least 80 and potentially much more.  Seems to prefer playing easier, big bodied teams with less pace.  Will get more than puopolo this week imo.

HolyGrail_2010

So Lower's sub history is quite worrying. Should I stick with him as D7 this week or go Puopolo instead?

S_Coach99

I wouldn't lower my standards

C-Dogg

stick with him, even though i hate him after he buckled me out of finals in supercoach :(

Luigi197

If it is who to start between Puopolo and Lower?
Current form suggests Pewy.
Current fixture suggest Pewy as he will get more ball with Carlton running into the Hawks backline quite a bit.

gpdemons

So who should I start in the backline? Pederson is amazing, but scored 22 on his last outing, Lower scored 10 last week but has a history of just randomly scoring 140, and Puopolo is playing well lately but is playing Carlton.
In the midfield I need to play one and I'm leaning towards Smith just because he's been really very good lately, Scully hasn't been in great form but I think he's capable of scoring huge this week.
In the forward line i need to play one and I am strongly considering Mzungu through recent form, but Krakouer playing Brisbane..

Any Thoughts??

Luigi197

Scully and Smith just miss out compared to Mzungu and Krakeour.