Broughton, Fisher, Birchall or Suckling- Please Help!

[Karmaboy]

I have to trade Newman, and have enough dough to take any of these players.

[hardnut]

Fisher probably most reliable but tends not to go HUGE very often and can be tagged out from time to time

Broughton/Suckling are similar prospects in that they can both go 60-140 but Broughtons recent form is good, having said that with Mundy and Barlow back can he stay in the middle?

Birchall - nah

Depends a bit on if you need an edge or just stability, if you're rolling the dice I like Suckling with a couple of weak opponents to come (he likes those) but if your team is already set for success then Fisher is a stable rock for the backline

[Karmaboy]

Depends a bit on if you need an edge or just stability, if you're rolling the dice I like Suckling with a couple of weak opponents to come (he likes those) but if your team is already set for success then Fisher is a stable rock for the backline

Yer i am looking for someone to take me through the finals series- Fisher? Magpies- Swans- Roos- Blues are his next four

[PowerToWin]

Fisher is definately the most consistent of the lot. I guess thats what you want at the pointy end of the season too. I would be happy to get 90 from Fisher for the next 4wks rather than 4 up and down scores from Suckling or Broughton.

[Karmaboy]

I went for Fisher based on his consistency- Thanks fellas!

[Grazz]

Yeh good move it was outa Fisher and Suckling for me with Birchall a very close third.
Goodluck.