Deledio or Green?

Started by heard, July 03, 2009, 02:00:45 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

who to go

Deledio
3 (33.3%)
Green
4 (44.4%)
Other
2 (22.2%)

Total Members Voted: 1

heard

hey guys im trading out rich but want to spend the least money  i can possible for other upgrades, im torn between going  Deledio or Brad Green can someone help me choose which would go better or if theres a better option to get someone <$400k cheers  :D

2Fat2Old

Whats wrong with Rich. He plays in the middle. He scores above 75 every week, He's a permanent player in the side & brisbane will play finals, won't drop him for a younger player like maybe the other clubs are starting to do.
Can you be sure Deledio & green will see the year out. Rich will.
Trades are like gold in finals.

Prospector_1

Insight 2Fat, great insight! It's the cheapest trade, for the least cost in trades!

2Fat2Old


heard

ok 2fat thanks ive taken that into account but just bcos iv seen the their BE's and its so tempting bcos its likely that neither or them will be this cheap again.. yes it could be likely that deledio may not play the year out with the new coach after dropping simmonds, bowden etc.
but im also just curious myself, deledio or green? and why

Prospector_1

Green is better value, and more important in the team (in the coaches eyes and mine).

freezer

keep rich or look elsewhere...

ronl

Sheer lunacy trading Rich for either of those two.  The Richmond and Melbourne footy clubs are in such a mess and their structures so wrong, that trading in players from either of those teams is frought with danger.

StantonLEGEND

the future captain of richmond..

Prospector_1

Stanton will be ... the future captain of richmond?