Ruck Options

[Generalsor]

My rucks: Cox,Smith
bench: J. Tippett, Bathie (and Petrie in the forwards)

His rucks: Cox, Sandilands
bench: Smith, J. Tippett (and Petrie in the forwards)

Now that Sandilands has been named i have a dilemma. To give me the edge i'm trying to decide which trade would be better. Switch Petrie to the rucks and bring in McEvoy or keep Petrie and trade Z Smith out for a 320k ruckmen (Ottens, Warnock, Jolly or Nic Nat)

Thoughts?

[LaHug]

Smith is playing according to AFL website: http://www.afl.com.au/teams/tabid/16469/default.aspx

[LeBron4MVP]

Thinking of getting rid of Smith, this week or next week.

This week: Double Trade

Smith to McEvoy , curnow/hibberd to callinan
Smith to Leuenberger, curnow/hibberd to callinan,
Smith to Mumford, curnow/hibberd, to callinan
Smith to Jolly, curnow/hibberd to callinan

Next Week: Double Trade

Smith to Goldstein, therefore ill have to play smith during rd 1 finals.

playing for prelim. current in top 4

should i risk playing smith or trade now? 5 trades 5k

[LaHug]

Go Smith to McEvoy now.

[Master Q]

Go Smith to McEvoy now.

[jk17]

In a kinda apoptotic fashion, I have to say BYE ( ;) ) to Petrie this week, but who for? 5 trades.

[Master Q]

 :)

[thewizz]

Same position. Thinking Mummy or McEvoy. About to toss a coin!
Also thinking about really rolling the dice and getting Sandi back - any thoughts or am I just living in "Bank world"?

[dreamkiller]

Is smith going to score well this week?

say 90+?

[JBs-Hawks]

no

[dreamkiller]

Thoughts. Need someone to trade for Smith

Smith to Anyone via double trade.

help fellas?

[Holz]

how many trades do you have left. I personally think its smart to keep smith unless you have plenty of trades and the rest of your team is set. I dont see to much difference in socring in Smith and these guys for the rest of the year. Would only double trade to Cox  or Sadi if he pulls a big score this week.

[Generalsor]

Really? Agonizing over this one guys - thoughts would be greatly appreciated

[hardnut]

Sandi was seen in the shops over here the the day still limping, he's not going to rack them up and may not even play.  Trading out Petrie goes against the grain ditching a premium with a huge ceiling, is this an elim final? If not then maybe roll the dice and hold your ground if yes then I'd be tempted to double trade and get Smith up to McEvoy or Mummy. Of the cheapies listed I'd go Jolly

[dreamkiller]

currently 5 trades 5k

rest of team finished. unless you dont count sylvia as part of a finished team.