384K Midfielder advice

[biggy]

hey guys, just need some advice on a midfielder trade. i've done some research and i need some help making the final descision.

I've got 119K in the bank, and upgrading Dangerfield to either:

Shiels or Barlow

Shiels has really established himself this year and has pulled back a bit in recent weeks. Whereas Barlow hasnt really started his season yet, so i feel he may be working into some pretty massive scores.

Any other midfield suggestions around 384K?
cheers

[Insider out]

im in the same position and am thinking Shiels is too hard to ignore.. Montagna is my other in consideration.... but barring being rested Shiels has a good run home, games at MCG where he scores well and a GF round 24 game against Gold Coast!!

[Fireballz]

Barlow all the way for me mate

[TheBeatles]

how much is D Thomas - might be cheaper next week too

[RiOtChEsS]

of those 2 id take Shiels...

[LaHug]

Barlow for me

[biggy]

yeah i'm keen on barlow as well, but compared to shiels run home its much tougher.
looking at barlow's statistics last year, he scored 146 against a strong collingwood team, hitting like 11 tackles. so definitely knows how to score well in tough games.

its good to say shiels has the GC in grand final, but you gotta make it to the grand final to reap those benefits.

thomas is around 391 from memory this week, not a bad option to look at.

[henry]

Bartel could be a good option at 375K, although he does have the bye next week.

[chaosAD]

Barlow no question