O'Keefe or Fyfe

[jfitty]

Hey guys,

Looking at two trade scenarios and wanting some advice as which one would be better:

Option 1:
Hibberd > 91K Player
Lynch > Fyfe
Jacobs > Rawlings

Option 2:
Hibberd > 91K Player
Lynch > O'Keefe
Puopolo > Johncock/Birchall/Rob Murphy

Not sure who to choose out of Fyfe and O'Keefe. Fyfe may hit a wall towards the end of the season, but O'Keefe has had a few ordinary games (for his standards).

Then I'm also looking to bring someone in to use as cover for finals in the backline. Getting O'Keefe would mean having around 400k to bring someone in, otherwise if I get Fyfe I'm thinking taking a risk on Rawlings, but keeping Puopolo as the emergency.

Any thoughts would be appreciated!

[roo boys!]

I think option one, Fyfe more consistent then O'Keefe IMO, but you shouldn't be getting Rawlings I don't reckon. Playing more of a shutdown defensive role lately. Who else can you afford around that area? If no-one good, then go with option 2, I'm just tentative about trading Puopolo out over Jacobs.

[jfitty]

I'd definitely prefer to trade Jacobs. If I get Fyfe in I'll only have 20k left over which makes it hard. Not a lot on offer apart from Rawlings, maybe Duffield or Malceski

[Ringo]

Have you got Rioli He is probably a better option with the Hawks finals run and around the same price.  O'Keefe seems to have dropped off in recent weeks.

Does this work for you Hibberd to Andreoli - maintains the DPP if Hibberd in mids.
Lynch to Rioli (Otherwise Fyfe)
Jacobs to Nicoski (like West Coast run home as well and with him playing forward not back in recent weeks may be a POD for you)

Hopefully the sums work out for you.

[charliesheen]

please don't grab rawlings.

[PICCOLLO]

I went rok and adcock last week.  Best combo if you are cash strapped imo.

[jfitty]

Actually Rioili could be a good option! Only problem would be the hamstring, if that goes then I'm about done!

I'm now thinking getting O'Keefe or Rioli, someone around that mark anyway, then trade Jacobs to Johncock. Getting Johncock for Jacobs could be the key move as the weeks I need him to play, Adelaide are playing Gold Coast and Richmond

[jfitty]

One thing I should have mentioned is that these are my last three trades. I might get in Fyfe (in form, not injury prone, won't be rested) and hang onto that last trade as long as I can