Second ruckman???

Started by Skullgove, August 07, 2011, 10:58:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which second ruckman?

Mcevoy
Leuenberger
Mumford
Other (please specify)
Jacobs (just added)
Sandi if he plays (just added)
Ryder ... (just added)

Skullgove

I already have big cox and plenty of $ (petrie and goldstein not incl as they have a bye)

Who to bring in this week for sudden death final?

TMurphBROWNLOW

I wanna keep an eye on this post :)

sizing up between leuenberger and mummy. I voted mummy for the reason that he has had more experience.
would anyone have any info on their past with the teams they come up against during our finals???

LaHug

Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on August 07, 2011, 11:25:39 PM
I wanna keep an eye on this post :)

sizing up between leuenberger and mummy. I voted mummy for the reason that he has had more experience.
would anyone have any info on their past with the teams they come up against during our finals???
Usually pretty easy to find just by going to their player page on this site. Chock full of information!

TMurphBROWNLOW


TigerBoy86

I traded out Sandi for Sam Jacobs a month ago... he's average 93 over those 4 games, he's unique and has games against Richmond and Gold Coast to come - though Rd 24 against the WCE could be a concern.

plugz19

yeah im looking at a z smith->mummy trade this week

pinochio

is mumford better then the burger???
...lions have a favourable draw while swans have a prelim final at skilled???

...although mummy would have to be nice and refreshed after a mid season hiatus :P

???

Skullgove

Mcevoy has the highest average of the three ...

thanme

Yeah surely McEvoy by a mile??

yorgis


navy.blueANDwhite

Leuenberger - GC, Coll, WCE, Syd
Mumford - Rich, StK, Geel, Bris
Jolly - StK, Bris, Freo, Geel
McEvoy - Coll, Syd, NM, Carl
Sam Jacbos - Geel, GC, Rich, WCE

IMO I would say:Mummy, McEvoy, Jolly, Jacobs, Burger
bold = home games

TMurphBROWNLOW

Quote from: navy.blueANDwhite on August 08, 2011, 08:23:15 PM
Leuenberger - GC, Coll, WCE, Syd
Mumford - Rich, StK, Geel, Bris
Jolly - StK, Bris, Freo, Geel
McEvoy - Coll, Syd, NM, Carl
Sam Jacbos - Geel, GC, Rich, WCE

IMO I would say:Mummy, McEvoy, Jolly, Jacobs, Burger
bold = home games

judging from that I'd say leu has one dominant game against a team with no legit ruckman, mummy has two, jolly two, mcevoy three and Jacobs three except last round.

pinochio

not sure but thinking leuy over mummy just???

Skullgove

I just added jacobs and sandi to the options.

If Sandi plays ... it could be a case of risk reward. Or is he shot for the year?

Skullgove

I have tentatively added ryder ... Eventhough he has a bye in tne last round, if he plays in the backlines for the remaining games he will score hundreds.