Everyones captains for first week of finals??????

[ossie85]

Nobody has chosen Marc Murphy! The guy is my Perma-Captain in SCPro, and hasn't let me down. Don't have him in my regular team though.

[roo boys!]

Last time I chose Franklin because I thought he would destroy weak opposition was against GC when he stank it up and got reported :-\

Poll is astounding !

Will try and see if I can pry some information from my opponent tomorrow, to see if he is chosing Judd.

who's team is better on paper?  yours or his?  if your team is better just play it safe.

Mine is.

[cortez]

I'm actually starting to think Adam goodes. 167 and 139 in past two weeks. Has Richmond this week and will want to prove a point after missing that shot last week. People thoughts?

[PICCOLLO]

Goodes is an unpredictable beast.  V richmond, he could go big but risky in a final.   judd's been too unpredictable to be confident in, esp given he has a quieter game after a big score.  He does have a great record v freo and at pattersons though so I can see why ppl are on him.  Going ablett, with pendles vc.  Mitchell v port or selwood v adelaide would have to be the safest bets this week.

[fever]

i think it depends on how you rate your team vs your opponents. if you think you're slightly outgunned (as i might be this week) then a captain like goodes or brennan (155 last time v bris) could be the gamble you need to take.

[thatguy]

Crowley tagged Judd last year and frustrated him to the point that Judd elbowed Pavlich in the face (and smehow got off).  Reckon he'll get him again.

think you will find mcphee tagged judd.

how you can go past pendles or swan for captain is beyond me.

[ben_020285]

Pendles for me. Has done no wrong all year, has the best SC average out of anybody and will not be subbed or rested during a game against the in form Saints.

[charliesheen]

Ablett has only hit the tonne once at the Gabba in 2010 out of a sample size of about 7 games.  Expecting Raines/Polkinghorne to go to him. 

Did anyone have Selwood captain in Round 17 at the Gabba where he scored 78 SC?

[roo boys!]

2010? How about in 2011?

[charliesheen]

2010? How about in 2011?

this is over his entire career playing at the Gabba. 

[charliesheen]

Chris Judds record at PS, since moving to Carlton

2008, Round   7, WCE, PS, 24 disposals, 112 SC
2009, Round   14, FRE, PS, 35 disposals, 165 SC
2010, Round   17, WCE, PS, 26 disposals, 110 SC
2010, Round   22, FRE, PS, 30 disposals, 145 SC

Dal Santo scord 133 SC when tagged against Mzungu, and Mzungu scored 113SC

[MarkPlow]

Who gets the big C

[charliesheen]

Selwood would probably be the safest choice.

[roo boys!]

Juddy

[roo boys!]

2010? How about in 2011?

this is over his entire career playing at the Gabba.

Ok. I'll be gooing with the crowd and choosing JUDDY