I need a NEW-MAN...who should it be?

Started by Jay, August 04, 2011, 06:37:13 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who should come in for newman

Broughton
20 (57.1%)
birchall
4 (11.4%)
suckling
2 (5.7%)
Bock
1 (2.9%)
stiffy
4 (11.4%)
Hurn
2 (5.7%)
S.martin
1 (2.9%)
Other (please comment)
1 (2.9%)

Total Members Voted: 3

powersuperkents

Fisher was the correct option. He doubled Broughton and you got Greggy when he was expensive and now he will drop in price. Plus you don't have the $120k upgrade bonus for selecting Fisher. Fisher also has easy opposition in the finals. If you already had fisher i would go Suckling 2nd. Just wait in a couple weeks Broughton will hit the $340k mark.

russs13

After a horror year Im sitting at 6 and 7th in my leagues and only 1 trade. I know I've left myself in a pretty bad spot. Being in 6th and 7th I have no second chance and am looking to at least make the next round. I still have Newman in my team and think its time to loose that last trade. I can get anyone but am not sure whether to get anyone from Carlton (Scotland and Gibbs) due to the bye in a few weeks.

My current backline is:

BACKS: R.Murphy, Suckling, Goddard, Fisher, Broughton, Deledio, Newman (Tape, Puopolo, L.Thompson)

As I said I can get anyone in the backline

Any helps good help

Cheers

Jay

WTF! i already hav fisher as you can see in the post where i listed my team! Hindsight is a great thing mate but broughton was gunning it! who wouldve thought he would score 65 points under his 5-game average??? But im happy becuase knowing my luck he wouldve done his knee!!!

And why are you tellin me this now after the trade has already been made???

Quote from: powersuperkents on August 07, 2011, 06:31:01 PM
Fisher was the correct option. He doubled Broughton and you got Greggy when he was expensive and now he will drop in price. Plus you don't have the $120k upgrade bonus for selecting Fisher. Fisher also has easy opposition in the finals. If you already had fisher i would go Suckling 2nd. Just wait in a couple weeks Broughton will hit the $340k mark.

da cooler

get on birchall, down on price last few weeks and has no more byes, plus the hawks go up against port at the MCG this week, it's a win-win situation, as he also has the ability to score big. :)

lewis

I like birchall against port this week. If you make it to the final Birchall against GC

GoLions

yeah birchall seems like the best option as u want someone who has no more byes because your cover doesnt look the best if u got gibbs/scotland

Ringo

Also have a look at Bock His average for last 5 is 104 against some good opposition.  Maybe might get you over the line compared to your opponent.

tkringle

I'm going to go Bock.. Playing soem great consistent footy lately, and will be a POD during my finals matches

powersuperkents

because how could I tell you broughton was the wrong choice if he hadnt scored the 64 yet.

Jay

Quote from: powersuperkents on August 09, 2011, 08:45:21 PM
because how could I tell you broughton was the wrong choice if he hadnt scored the 64 yet.
Well u telling me it was the wrong choice NOW isnt going to help at all is it???

powersuperkents

yeah sorry bout that. I'm sure broughton will pay off still but I would of chose fisher or suckling

Jay


powersuperkents

sorry I got you mixed up with the other guy that just butting into this topic on thursday who was deciding whether to get fisher or broughton :z.

Jay

Quote from: powersuperkents on August 09, 2011, 11:41:01 PM
sorry I got you mixed up with the other guy that just butting into this topic on thursday who was deciding whether to get fisher or broughton :z.
No worries!

Wish i had got suckling or even stiffy as i would still have $$$ left over! Oh well im sure gregory will get back to his 130ppg average!!!

Grazz

Birchall or if you want a unique Gram might not be a bad option now the Saints have found some form.