I need a NEW-MAN...who should it be?

[Jay]

The obvious one is gregory but birchall and suckling are 80k cheaper And johncock is120k cheaper...so the question effectively is...is broughton 80k better than birchall/suckling and also is he 120k better than johncock???

My backs are: goddard gibbs deledio enright NEWMAN fisher murphy

Thoughts?

Cheers

[Ringo]

have a look at Nathan Bock I know playing Geelong this week but then has a good run home.  has averaged over 100 for last 5 weeks and only $431k as well.

[Jay]

have a look at Nathan Bock I know playing Geelong this week but then has a good run home.  has averaged over 100 for last 5 weeks and only $431k as well.

yep added to poll mate

[Jay]

FYI im looking for the player who will score the most in SC finals

Cheers

P.S broughton is leading the poll with birchall outright second

[Jay]

I know the pun in the title is terrible  ;D

Doesnt meen u cant help me out!

Please keep the votes/comments coming

Cheers

[enzedder]

I brought in Fisher but from that list I'd go Broughton over Stiffy

[Jay]

I brought in Fisher but from that list I'd go Broughton over Stiffy

Cheers mate i think i will go broughton. But the question im asking myself is...is broughtom 120k better than stiffy??? Also is broughton 80k better than birchal???

I think broughton is the best optiln but then you have birchall and stiffy and bock who are a lot cheaper!

Thoughts

[enzedder]

Broughton's last 2 months have been great. Stiffy has really got things going recently too...was a shame he got injured a cpl of weeks back would've scored 150+...if you need the cash for future trades then go Stiffy of the two there's little diff IMO...I've got both.

[roo boys!]

Broughton IS 80k better. Get him.

[Jay]

Broughton's last 2 months have been great. Stiffy has really got things going recently too...was a shame he got injured a cpl of weeks back would've scored 150+...if you need the cash for future trades then go Stiffy of the two there's little diff IMO...I've got both.

Well getting broughton would use up all my cash which isnt ideal! Stiffy is very risky but could pay off handsomely as he is loads cheaper. Or should i compromise and get birchall???

Cheers

Broughton IS 80k better. Get him.

is he 120k better than stiffy???

[roo boys!]

Broughton IS 80k better. Get him.

is he 120k better than stiffy???
[/quote]
I reckon. Stiffy has been a slightly different player since his injury against essendon IMO.

[Jay]

Ok definitely leaning towards broughton...anyone want to convince me that gregory isnt 120k better tham stiffy???

You have half an hour...GO!!!

[enzedder]

Stiffy's opponents look more attractive...GC, Rich, Bris... Geel (AAMI) WCE compared to Broughton's StK, Carl, NM, Coll, WB

[Jay]

Stiffy's opponents look more attractive...GC, Rich, Bris... Geel (AAMI) WCE compared to Broughton's StK, Carl, NM, Coll, WB

Great Point! Enzedder...wot Would you do in my situation??

Keep the suggestions coming please!

Thanks

[enzedder]

Stiffy's opponents look more attractive...GC, Rich, Bris... Geel (AAMI) WCE compared to Broughton's StK, Carl, NM, Coll, WB

Great Point! Enzedder...wot Would you do in my situation??

Keep the suggestions coming please!

Thanks

Think I'd still go Broughton based on his last 5 games or so but really not much between them and if you've got trades to come $120k could be useful later...perhaps more so than the difference between these two...your call though.