The Heath Shaw Betting Scandal

Started by navy.blueANDwhite, July 27, 2011, 10:01:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which trade option?

Broughton
Suckling
Birchall
Martin
Fisher
Waters

navy.blueANDwhite

My backline is:
Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Enright, Adcock, Shaw, Stanley (Duffield, Puopolo, Talia)

Out comes Heath Shaw but I'm confused into who to bring into my team.
I am sitting 4th on the league ladder and the top 3 teams have Fisher.
Yes he is cheap but I don't really want him. I need some sort of smokey!

please vote  :)

Grazz

Suckling and Birchall could be a couple of options.

Zarts

Xavier ellis ;)

not even joking :P

97crows98

I brought in Birchall last week because I was up against Dr DT, but would have go Suckling if he played last week. I also have Fisher already.

navy.blueANDwhite

the top 2 teams have suckling and for some reason im not a big fan.
any thought on waters? had him last year and i fell in love after the 155 against geelong!

bundyboy

love the hawks game - and have been a suckling fan all year....

BUT...

Elllis back, Hodge firing, Birchall and Suckling all playing running half back type roles - and all sharing it...

I think the days of Suckling getting 110+ are over...think these boys are going to be sharing it too much for any one to score particularly well any more...

Broughton on fire  - and hard to go past him compared to the rest...
Fisher - would have been my no. 1 choice, but has been making me doubt him lately...
Martin and Waters - no reason not to go there - they are generating good numbers, but not quite as good as Broughton.

navy.blueANDwhite

voting is tight,
keep voting please :D

PowerBug

My vote to Waters has just leveled him and Broughton up.

bomberboy0618

I think Fisher is a safe bet, but get a second opinion as im not 100% shaw.