Callinan or the Trades?

[stevemac]

This is somewhat similar to http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,40373.0.html

I am currently in 7th position in my league with an easy run home looking for a league victory.

I have 8 trades left and hoping to make two upgrades before the finals (one DEF, one MID, as seen in red), leaving me with 6 trades for the finals.

The prospect of replacing a redundant Cam Richardson with a MPP Ian Callinan (in blue) is tempting enough to use an extra trade and take 5 into the finals.

What's better, an MPP Callinan or taking 6 trades into the finals?

For what it's worth, this is my team.

Gibbs, Enright, Goddard, Deledio, Fisher, Duffield, Hibberd (Suckling), PUOPOLO, TALIA, JACOBS,
Swan, Pendlebury, Boyd, Mitchell, Montagna, Sidebottom (Ablett), D SWALLOW, MZUNGU, WALLIS
Cox, Sandilands, LOBBE, DERICKX
Fyfe, Franklin, Pavlich, OKeefe, Goodes, Sylvia, N Riewoldt, HOWE, LYNCH (GC), RICHARDSON (CALLINAN)

[GoLions]

do it when callinans named

[Chopps]

just out of interest why you trading sidebottom, why not swallow?

[plugz19]

yeahh, think its a good move
just allows you that flexibility, and just in case general soreness rears its ugly head you will have better cover

[stevemac]

thanks guys

chopps you just blew my mind! i had my mind set on a sidebottom upgrade for the past 6 weeks and swallow as permanent bench :S never thought of switching them

[Holz]

i brought in callinan through a double trade to leave me with 2. You have more than enough trades even for league.