Callinan or Talia

[powersuperkents]

state your points once voted
and when is callinan returning?
and will jeremy howe keep playing sub? because if he does i dont want him in my team

[TheBeatles]

callinan this week they say ;D

[Master Q]

Wait till teams is the easiest answer  ;D  :P

[The Grundles]

callinan might be touch and go...talia def expected to play.  I expect they will prolly give Cali a week in the reserves to test that hammy ;)

[Capper]

i have read on another thread that callinan is expected back this week, but will have to wait till teams announced

[powersuperkents]

was jeremy howe starting as sub a one time thing or not?

[The Grundles]

was jeremy howe starting as sub a one time thing or not?

I think you will find that is more of a permanant thing now....get rid of him!

[powersuperkents]

was jeremy howe starting as sub a one time thing or not?

I think you will find that is more of a permanant thing now....get rid of him!

cheers im gonna keep t. lynch my rule is never keep subs

[maccar86]

callinan had the bigger wraps coming into the season until he was injured. played 2 games and go re-injured. his doesnt seem very sustainable and might need a week in the reserves. barring injury he will play out the year in the seniors.

talia has looked decent in his first 2 games and youd think hed play out the season in the seniors if he maintains current form, which is impossible to predict.

if named, id choose callinan only because i see his potential to score to be better and as cover during finals or important league games. i have talia but only because i downgraded otten in my backs

[glam77]

unless you have a bucket load of trades left, none of those options.

i'd say talia or calinan are purely downgrade targets.
If you can pocket $150k from a downgrade of another player warming your bench then go ahead.

[CFC 1979]

Ian Callinan (hamstring) pulled up sore at training & won't play in #aflsaintscrows. Jaensch (shoulder) also ruled out, but Johncock OK

there's your answer

[Ermaz]

the MPP fwd/mid for calinan is ideal, even if he doesnt play. lynch to calinan for me

[plugz19]

if your downgrading a fwd for sure i'd go callinan, and the mpp with the mids is more valuable than talia's mpp with def (unless you have gilbert, mckernan etc etc)