Defender troubles

[Fireballz]

Hey guys! The worst trade i made this year is Grimes -> Pratt and I'm sick of hanging on to him. I need to trade him and it's between these 5 studs.
Please vote and/or comment!

[Zarts]

fisher

[Fireballz]

Any danger of getting some votes here?

I was leaning towards Broughton with his form revival of late....

[Fred Hollows]

yeh i would go broughton

[Sleeken]

The only reason I wouldn't get broughton is because of barlow and mundy coming back into the team...It might be a coincidence but didn't broughton score in the 50s when Barlow last played? (freo did get belted by Melbourne too)

[Fireballz]

Cheers everyone! Would have loved to hold off on Fisher until next week (or the week after) but i do not have that luxury so the trade's been made.
Wish me luck!