nice and simple -- please give thoughts

thatguy · July 14, 2011, 02:03:10 PM

Heath Shaw vs Greg Broughton.

who would you pick and why?

Broughton in midfield pumping out some big scores but will he stay, Shaw inconsistent. to finish off a backline already consisting of Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Suckling, Fisher and Heppell. keeping Lower as bench cover, upgrading hibberd.

Fred Hollows · July 14, 2011, 02:53:51 PM

no thoughts ;D

Macman5005 · July 14, 2011, 02:59:17 PM

Tough call. Will Broughton keep playing midfield when Barlow, Sandi and Mundy are back in the line up? Because of that I would go Shaw as his role is defined at Collingwood and Freo do have a tough run home IMO.

biggsy · July 14, 2011, 05:07:45 PM

Shaw 4 sure IMO

BGK · July 14, 2011, 05:23:49 PM

Quote from: Macman5005 on July 14, 2011, 02:59:17 PM
Tough call. Will Broughton keep playing midfield when Barlow, Sandi and Mundy are back in the line up? Because of that I would go Shaw as his role is defined at Collingwood and Freo do have a tough run home IMO.

I have to agree with Macman here. Broughton's scores have really needed the midfield time and i can see that reducing when Mundy and Barlow fit back in.

Windigo · July 14, 2011, 05:33:09 PM

Both have their flaws. Shaw for me....JUST. ;)

yorgis · July 14, 2011, 10:10:12 PM

both are a bit rollercoastery but shaws role is pretty clearly defined whereas broughton plays anywhere and everywhere

like u windy shawy just