Best defender?

Started by Sleeken, July 11, 2011, 01:34:37 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Pick one.

Birchall
3 (20%)
Fisher
5 (33.3%)
Broughton
5 (33.3%)
Martin
2 (13.3%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Sleeken

Looking to bring someone in for lower so Adcock can sit on the bench. Leaning towards broughton or Martin as birchall has a bye this week and I have an important league match. Fisher is very consistent but has a lower scoring potential. Already have goddard, suckling, shaw etc. Cheers!

Macman5005

After Fishers low score he will be a bargain for what he delivers in a few weeks. Hold off and get him (IMO)

Sleeken

You make a good point but this will be my last upgrades (2 trades) and the final trades are just for swapping around Judd and Selwood comes finals time...so I don't need extra cash. I'm more concerned with who will average more.

Need to go

Lower -> Defender
Dawes -> Fwd under 340k (Lecras/Higgins)

I'm not sure fisher would drop sufficiently in price for me to upgrade my fwds to someone better than Lecras or Higgins, seeing as Lower will most likely drop in value as well.

Windigo

Fisher is a great DT option but as soon as he is tagged cannot get into open space where he scores most of his points from a Mark & kick.

He will hurt you in some games but delivers in most. I bought Fisher a few weeks ago fully knowing what may happen when he is tagged.

But a good option none-the-less.  ;)

Sleeken

Quote from: Windigo on July 11, 2011, 02:07:56 PM
Fisher is a great DT option but as soon as he is tagged cannot get into open space where he scores most of his points from a Mark & kick.

He will hurt you in some games but delivers in most. I bought Fisher a few weeks ago fully knowing what may happen when he is tagged.

But a good option none-the-less.  ;)

Thanks, Saints do have a reasonable run coming up with Gold Coast and Adelaide so I'll definitely be considering getting him.

Windigo


Sleeken