Ask Q (8/7/11)

[LaHug]

I don't think you need to do anything to your Forward line, it's pretty nice.

Up to you if you aren't confident with Smith.

Well, I'm not very confident with Smith and that also means relying having two forwards out for the North bye. Best thing would be trading Dawes to someone but are there any good forward options at Sylvia's price or cheaper?

[Flame]

Q..do I do the smith to lobbe trade. It would give me cash to do my last 2 upgrades in defence. 8 trades left. Other ruck man cox and vardy so bit thin.

[Master Q]

I don't think you need to do anything to your Forward line, it's pretty nice.

Up to you if you aren't confident with Smith.

Well, I'm not very confident with Smith and that also means relying having two forwards out for the North bye. Best thing would be trading Dawes to someone but are there any good forward options at Sylvia's price or cheaper?

Well you've got a good forward line so not really, Sylvia is a great option though. Come to think of it, I'd go Dawes to Sylvia and if you aren't happy to rely on Smith you could trade any of your ruckmen to Lobbe or any other guys you like.

[Master Q]

Q..do I do the smith to lobbe trade. It would give me cash to do my last 2 upgrades in defence. 8 trades left. Other ruck man cox and vardy so bit thin.

What about Vardy to Lobbe? Is that possible?

[miegs3]

I'll throw a quick one it to see if you can answer (I think it's been asked a bit in some forms).

At this stage I've got 12 trades left and only $8,700 in the bank.

Should I make a ruck move to get better coverage for Sandi or to get some extra cash?
Lobbe being the target for Smith or Sandi are my thoughts.

Team is:

Back: Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Heppell, Adcock, Stanley, Puopolo (Lower, Otten, Jacobs)
Mid: Boyd, Pendlebury, Mitchell, Ablett, Swan, Bartel (Kerr, Buckley, Mzungu)
Ruck:Cox, Hale (Smith, Sandilands)
Forward: Goodes, Chapman, Petrie, Riewoldt, Krakouer, Prestia, Lynch (Pavlich, Knights, Richardson)

Thanks

[LaHug]

I don't think you need to do anything to your Forward line, it's pretty nice.

Up to you if you aren't confident with Smith.

Well, I'm not very confident with Smith and that also means relying having two forwards out for the North bye. Best thing would be trading Dawes to someone but are there any good forward options at Sylvia's price or cheaper?

Well you've got a good forward line so not really, Sylvia is a great option though. Come to think of it, I'd go Dawes to Sylvia and if you aren't happy to rely on Smith you could trade any of your ruckmen to Lobbe or any other guys you like.

If I go Dawes to Sylvia (may as well wait til next week), then I can move Petrie to forwards and not have to rely on Smith. May as well do nothing this week though as Lobbe is no better than Smith imo. So, I'll be doing nothing, just like I'd originally planned ;)

[Master Q]

I'll throw a quick one it to see if you can answer (I think it's been asked a bit in some forms).

At this stage I've got 12 trades left and only $8,700 in the bank.

Should I make a ruck move to get better coverage for Sandi or to get some extra cash?

Team is:

Back: Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Heppell, Adcock, Stanley, Puopolo (Lower, Otten, Jacobs)
Mid: Boyd, Pendlebury, Mitchell, Ablett, Swan, Bartel (Kerr, Buckley, Mzungu)
Ruck:Cox, Hale (Smith, Sandilands)
Forward: Goodes, Chapman, Petrie, Riewoldt, Krakouer, Prestia, Lynch (Pavlich, Knights, Richardson)

Thanks

Only upside with Hale is that he plays GC in the last round  -  last time they met he scored 70-odd. Trade him out.

[Master Q]

5 Minutes Left.

[Flame]

Q..do I do the smith to lobbe trade. It would give me cash to do my last 2 upgrades in defence. 8 trades left. Other ruck man cox and vardy so bit thin.

What about Vardy to Lobbe? Is that possible?

Yes could do that..just wouldn't get as much cash I guess. I could sit tight for a few weeks!

[Master Q]

Q..do I do the smith to lobbe trade. It would give me cash to do my last 2 upgrades in defence. 8 trades left. Other ruck man cox and vardy so bit thin.

What about Vardy to Lobbe? Is that possible?

Yes could do that..just wouldn't get as much cash I guess. I could sit tight for a few weeks!

Vardy's BE is 60-odd. Isn't going much higher.

[miegs3]

I'll throw a quick one it to see if you can answer (I think it's been asked a bit in some forms).

At this stage I've got 12 trades left and only $8,700 in the bank.

Should I make a ruck move to get better coverage for Sandi or to get some extra cash?

Team is:

Back: Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Heppell, Adcock, Stanley, Puopolo (Lower, Otten, Jacobs)
Mid: Boyd, Pendlebury, Mitchell, Ablett, Swan, Bartel (Kerr, Buckley, Mzungu)
Ruck:Cox, Hale (Smith, Sandilands)
Forward: Goodes, Chapman, Petrie, Riewoldt, Krakouer, Prestia, Lynch (Pavlich, Knights, Richardson)

Thanks

Only upside with Hale is that he plays GC in the last round  -  last time they met he scored 70-odd. Trade him out.

I hadn't thought abut Hale as much with him having a low BE this week, but ultimately I'd be leaving Smith or Hale as 3rd cover so you think get rid of Hale and bring in Lobbe to set up some future cash?

[Master Q]

Extending the Locked time as I need to go somewhere quickly. Back in 10-15 minutes.

[Windigo]

Should I get Cloke or play it safe & get ROK? Even with 4 out during multi.

Was hell bent on getting Cloke & still confident on him. BUT.

[Master Q]

Back.

I'll throw a quick one it to see if you can answer (I think it's been asked a bit in some forms).

At this stage I've got 12 trades left and only $8,700 in the bank.

Should I make a ruck move to get better coverage for Sandi or to get some extra cash?

Team is:

Back: Gibbs, Deledio, Goddard, Heppell, Adcock, Stanley, Puopolo (Lower, Otten, Jacobs)
Mid: Boyd, Pendlebury, Mitchell, Ablett, Swan, Bartel (Kerr, Buckley, Mzungu)
Ruck:Cox, Hale (Smith, Sandilands)
Forward: Goodes, Chapman, Petrie, Riewoldt, Krakouer, Prestia, Lynch (Pavlich, Knights, Richardson)

Thanks

Only upside with Hale is that he plays GC in the last round  -  last time they met he scored 70-odd. Trade him out.

I hadn't thought abut Hale as much with him having a low BE this week, but ultimately I'd be leaving Smith or Hale as 3rd cover so you think get rid of Hale and bring in Lobbe to set up some future cash?

Exactly. I'd much rather have Smith than Hale.

Should I get Cloke or play it safe & get ROK? Even with 4 out during multi.

Was hell bent on getting Cloke & still confident on him. BUT.

ROK. Easy one. Especially if you are going for league, as Pies are against Cats in the last round.

[Master Q]

Any last questions before I lock the thread?