Ask Q (8/7/11)

[Master Q]

It's that time of the week and you know how it works.

Shoot.

***EDIT: Please post how many trades you have left.

Thanks
-Q

[pinochio]

going 2 comps one for overall and one for league...

have enright/Stevie J from cats and deledio/goodes from last multi bye
- will jack affect roks scoring like in 2/3 of roks worst games
- will chappy get injured
- sitting top 2 in all leagues so hopefully rd 21 cats bye will be an anomaly for my league results anyway :P


Who do i get Chappy or ROK???

[Arradin]

I am going to get Lobbe in to make some money. The question is do I trade sandilands or Zac smith??
I can still make the upgrades I want to make for this week and next week if I trade out Smith.
I guess the question is should I hold onto sandi and hope that he plays well straight away or do i trade him and pocket some extra cash?? either way i can make the immediate upgrades I want to make.

Cheers

[Master Q]

going 2 comps one for overall and one for league...

have enright/Stevie J from cats and deledio/goodes from last multi bye
- will jack affect roks scoring like in 2/3 of roks worst games
- will chappy get injured
- sitting top 2 in all leagues so hopefully rd 21 cats bye will be an anomaly for my league results anyway :P


Who do i get Chappy or ROK???

No I don't think Jack will affect his chances, and I highly doubt Chappy will get injured, but there is a chance he will.

Sydney play Brisbane in the last round which means a good chance ROK will score highly, compared to Chappy who plays Pies in the last round.

I think ROK will be the better option, but Chappy is more likely to pull out the scores.

I think ROK is safer TBH. Go ROK.

[Master Q]

I am going to get Lobbe in to make some money. The question is do I trade sandilands or Zac smith??
I can still make the upgrades I want to make for this week and next week if I trade out Smith.
I guess the question is should I hold onto sandi and hope that he plays well straight away or do i trade him and pocket some extra cash?? either way i can make the immediate upgrades I want to make.

Cheers

Extra cash isn't that great if you don't have many trades left, but I don't know how many trades you have so...

Freo doesn't have the best of runs home, but I doubt Lobbe will score as well as Sandi. If you are confident in Smith and your other ruck I'd trade Smith, if not then I guess Sandi. But personally I think you should go Smith.

[LaHug]

With 5 trades left and very little cash in the bank ($21,600), do I rely on Zac Smith for the rest of the year with Petrie forward, or do I trade Dawes to a forward or Smith to a ruck? Can afford a $318,000 ruck or a $304,800 forward.

[Master Q]

In future please post how many trades you have left.

Thanks

-Q

[korza]

Hi Q

My prioirty is to progress in the eliminator, with stuff all trades left should i trade Richardson/Harper to Lobbe ?


KORZA

[Arradin]

Sorry Q when I checked back I saw the how many trades left. By the way I still have 12 if that makes a difference

[Master Q]

With 5 trades left and very little cash in the bank ($21,600), do I rely on Zac Smith for the rest of the year with Petrie forward, or do I trade Dawes to a forward or Smith to a ruck? Can afford a $318,000 ruck or a $304,800 forward.

Is Cox your other ruck?

Hi Q

My prioirty is to progress in the eliminator, with stuff all trades left should i trade Richardson/Harper to Lobbe ?


KORZA

If you don't care about the amount of trades, yeh I guess, but I'm not excited about Lobbe.

[JackBeQuick]

Hey Q
who to play: Smith v Lobbe

[Master Q]

Sorry Q when I checked back I saw the how many trades left. By the way I still have 12 if that makes a difference

If your team isn't complete, and Cox is your other ruck, and you are confident in Smith and your other rucks, then trade Sandi.

If those don't apply, then my previous post applies.

Hey Q
who to play: Smith v Lobbe

Flip a coin. Safe bet is Smith, if you want a high score than Lobbe but that could backfire if you get what I mean.

[LaHug]

With 5 trades left and very little cash in the bank ($21,600), do I rely on Zac Smith for the rest of the year with Petrie forward, or do I trade Dawes to a forward or Smith to a ruck? Can afford a $318,000 ruck or a $304,800 forward.

Is Cox your other ruck?

Yep.
Rucks: Cox, Smith (Jippett, McCauley)

Fwds: Goodes, Harvey, Chapman, Franklin, Petrie, Riewoldt, Pavlich (Dawes, Howe, Richardson, [I. Smith DPP])

If I do a double trade I can afford anyone in either position but only be left with 3 trades.

[Master Q]

I don't think you need to do anything to your Forward line, it's pretty nice.

Up to you if you aren't confident with Smith.

[Master Q]

I'm locking this at 7:30 EST, so get your questions in quick... I need to look after my team  :P