do you think the vics cheated in the ej whitten game last night

[Spuds11]

i really think the all stars should of won what do you think

[Jake8]

no but what does this habe to do with SC? just asking

[Spuds11]

its bye week dosent have to have anything to do with sc

[PowerBug]

The vics didn't cheat, Gary Lyon got into their heads. Fitzy kicked that goal, he kicked it before the umpy blew his whistle, which is the rule. That happened in Rd1 Pies v Port, Swan kikced the ball after the siren but before the whistle, thus a goal was given.

[Spuds11]

right  thus the goal fitzy kicked should of stood he kicked it before the siren and a mile before the umpire blew his whistle

[Bennyy]

Who cares? Its a charity game!! Get a life!

[twinkle]

I don't the normal AFL rules applied to much of the game...it was just a charity bash!

[Fenno]

The vics didn't cheat, Gary Lyon got into their heads. Fitzy kicked that goal, he kicked it before the umpy blew his whistle, which is the rule. That happened in Rd1 Pies v Port, Swan kikced the ball after the siren but before the whistle, thus a goal was given.

better check the rules on that one because your wrong. Ball must be kicked before the siren but it the umpires call if the kick was made. Nothing to do with the umpires whisle

[ossie85]

You guys are like those people who argue about Wrestling.... it's all rigged anyway :)

Amazing how close these games always turn out to be lol

[Spuds11]

Who cares? Its a charity game!! Get a life!

i got 3 words for you bennyy go flower yourself

[pyronerd]

agree with bennyy, besides, in '06 freo got given a win where the siren was meant to have gone but the umpy didnt blow the whistle where a point was kicked by the saints after the clock ran down to 0

[valkorum]

agree with bennyy, besides, in '06 freo got given a win where the siren was meant to have gone but the umpy didnt blow the whistle where a point was kicked by the saints after the clock ran down to 0

Sirengate

And the kick was at the same time as the siren therefore it should have counted.  Gary Lyon cheated - I hope he can live with himself for that.

[bomberboy0618]

agree with bennyy, besides, in '06 freo got given a win where the siren was meant to have gone but the umpy didnt blow the whistle where a point was kicked by the saints after the clock ran down to 0

Sirengate

And the kick was at the same time as the siren therefore it should have counted.  Gary Lyon cheated - I hope he can live with himself for that.

I was there, and it certainly wasnt. It was about 3 seconds afterwards.

[valkorum]

Watch the replay BB.  The kick was at the same time as the siren

[Maca24]

I think you will find that it was after.
Anyway it was a charity game, they clearly get told to make it close every year.