Swan or Frankiln

[choppa77]

Looking at getting rid of Harris & Knights this week for Callinan & either Swan or Franklin

D-Gibbs,Adcock,Suckling,Goddard,Heppell,Lower,Lids (Otten,Stanley,Howard)
M-Boyd, Pendles, GAJ,Hodge,Cotchin,Harris (Selwood,Hibberd,Mzungu)
R-Petrie,Smith (Cox,Vardy)
F-Chappy,Goodes,NRoo,Pav,Higgins,Sylvia (Knights,McKernan,JTipp)

Looking either:
Knights > Callinan; Harris > Swan or
Harris > Callinan; Knights > Franklin

Sh!t ranking (~14k), but somehow still in eliminator, so thinking Buddy option to avoid donut next week(if I make it)

Which is better?

[Silenced_1]

Swan will rack up more points I believe and has had both byes. He is quite fit due to his trip to Arizona.

Franklin however, has the DPP link if u need.

I would go Swan for Harris and Knights to Callinan

Hope this helps

[matt1985]

I'd probably go Swan too, he is at a very nice price at the moment and looks like he could be back in form!

[Possumo]

Swan will rack up more points I believe and has had both byes. He is quite fit due to his trip to Arizona.

Franklin however, has the DPP link if u need.

I would go Swan for Harris and Knights to Callinan

Hope this helps

Uh... Franklin is not a DPP mate...

As for the trades, you already have 6 premium mids (although Cotchin is borderline) so why bring in a 7th? Selwood is back in 2 weeks, so ideally you would want a DPP forward/mid (especially since your forward bench is looking pretty fragile) ... I'd say Fyfe for league, but of course you're in the eliminator, so perhaps Harvey? Callinan would be a great value option too... but who is your current 7th forward? You've only listed 9 players in the forward line in your post.

[choppa77]

Sorry - I Smith is 7th fwd at the moment.
Will switch Petrie back to Fwd after this week & play Cox & Z Smith for most of the year I think

[Possumo]

Sorry - I Smith is 7th fwd at the moment.
Will switch Petrie back to Fwd after this week & play Cox & Z Smith for most of the year I think

Alright, that makes your team already pretty damn strong... how many trades do you have left and how much cash? Callinan and Cloke/Franklin would be pretty decent trades, swapping Sylvia for Callinan to play him this week in your mids, and playing Cloke/Franklin as your 6th, with Smith as your 7th and Callinan as a forward emergency... sounds good to me! I'm actually not that keen on Cloke myself, but his form looks good and he doesn't have any more byes (Franklin does in 2 weeks which could be a problem if you're still in the eliminator.

[Jackina]

Swan. I always think its better to put all premiums in your mids and at swans price he is a bargain! Your forward line doesn't look like it needs too much more work if petrie's going back there after this week.

[Windigo]

Swan, too easy.  ;)

[The F.A.R.K.]

Swan because with the way franklin is kicking this year there is no way the FARK team can teach him anything

[melowen204]

Swan because with the way franklin is kicking this year there is no way the FARK team can teach him anything

+1   FARK TEAM lol.

[Windigo]

Hey FARK. Shouldn't you be: F.A.R.K

:P

[choppa77]

Swan. I always think its better to put all premiums in your mids and at swans price he is a bargain! Your forward line doesn't look like it needs too much more work if petrie's going back there after this week.

6 trades $31.5k

[Possumo]

Swan. I always think its better to put all premiums in your mids and at swans price he is a bargain! Your forward line doesn't look like it needs too much more work if petrie's going back there after this week.

He already has 6 premium mids though... Selwood is only out for 2 more weeks. If you're thinking that Cotchin isn't a premium mid, your probably right, but I'm not sure whether it's worth having him as a bench player... too much money sitting on the pine really. I'd prefer a ddp premium if I'm going to have one on the bench. If the OP wants to trade Cotchin to Swan though, I would say that would be a decent trade.

[CFC 1979]

Swan

[Possumo]

I love it how people don't read :p