Ask Ziplock

[Ziplock]

Do i do a double and get Sam Fisher ? or
do i take a punt and do a straight swap Hibberd to Gram ?

Fisher with a double trade- he's shown much more than gram this season, is a far safer option.

[Ziplock]

So whos the better defender - DT related

S.Fisher - no byes, very consistent but not renowned  for big 100's,

or

Suckling - hawks are playing keep-e-offs style of football out of defence where they chip it around, which means big points, while being cheap, they are still points, but hawks have 1 more bye

Am trading out Lower this week for one of these boys

Honestly, the difference between them on poitns average isn't much- fisher is a hair cheaper, a more proven premium, and has no byes left.

Don't get me wrong, I love suckling, but if I had to choose between them atm, I would pick fisher in a  heartbeat.

[Ziplock]

I would look to Mcevoy, since he has no more byes left and has been firing.

If I trade to McEvoy I'll be left with 5 trades and $10,800 in the bank.  Is this enough trades/money to have left, considering I will want to upgrade either a rookie forward or Yarran to a premium (I'm thinking Fyfe after his bye) at some point?

so with a double trade, 3 trades will be a bit tight. But  think of it this way

fielding bailey over mcevoy is like a 30-40 point loss each week. Fielding a premo fwd over yarran is like a 20-25 point loss each week. Seems clear which one is worse :P

[Chelskiman]

Ok, I'll make a decision tomorrow when I'm less drunk. :P

[dreamkiller]

hey zip thinking of getting in callinan this week to free up cash next week

currently on 40,100 left and 9 trades

thinking of going

pitt to callinan
lower to birchall

i also have other trading options such as curnow, hibberd, puopolo, lynch

thoughts

[Problems]

Zippeeee, got a few 'who should play' Qs for you

Backs (1 needed)
Do I trust JAdcock@home v Port
or Lower@home v GC
or Jacobs@Gabba v Bris
or Hibberd@Etihad v Geel

Fwds (2 needed)
NRoo@Etihad v NthMelb
ISmith@MCG v Coll
Prestia@Subiaco v Freo
CamRicho@Etihad v StK

Also how do you reckon Sam Iles will go this week? I've had to bench Sammy (who's provided great coverage over the last 2 weeks) with the return of Bartel and Montagna, good move or bad move?

Thanks pal

[Ziplock]

Ok, I'll make a decision tomorrow when I'm less drunk. :P

you should do that :P

that being said, my two drunk trades worked out ok :P

[Ziplock]

Zippeeee, got a few 'who should play' Qs for you

Backs (1 needed)
Do I trust JAdcock@home v Port
or Lower@home v GC
or Jacobs@Gabba v Bris
or Hibberd@Etihad v Geel

Fwds (2 needed)
NRoo@Etihad v NthMelb
ISmith@MCG v Coll
Prestia@Subiaco v Freo
CamRicho@Etihad v StK

Also how do you reckon Sam Iles will go this week? I've had to bench Sammy (who's provided great coverage over the last 2 weeks) with the return of Bartel and Montagna, good move or bad move?

Thanks pal

Adcock hands down

NRoo and Smith I guess, although Smith is a bit of a punt.

Bartel and Montag both deserve their spot over Iles. Fine move. That being said, he looks like solid cover.

[PowerBug]

Hey. I'm stuck on my two trades for the week. Sandilands down to who and Hibberd/Prestia/Didak up to Pendlebury.

9 trades, $24,700.

[Ziplock]

hey zip thinking of getting in callinan this week to free up cash next week

currently on 40,100 left and 9 trades

thinking of going

pitt to callinan
lower to birchall

i also have other trading options such as curnow, hibberd, puopolo, lynch

thoughts

sounds good. I would consider fisher over Birchall though- no more byes left and has, from memory, a similar if not superior average.

Pitt should go- anyone from port adelaide gets first dropping priority :P

[Ziplock]

Hey. I'm stuck on my two trades for the week. Sandilands down to who and Hibberd/Prestia/Didak up to Pendlebury.

9 trades, $24,700.

Hey PB.

I guess if you're forced to downgrade sandi, rather than sideways to mcevoy/leuen/goldy, then lobbe is probably your best bet- his DT stocks have risen with the retirement of brogan at the end of the year,  + he's mpp (if that tickles your pickle).

[dreamkiller]

hey zip thinking of getting in callinan this week to free up cash next week

currently on 40,100 left and 9 trades

thinking of going

pitt to callinan
lower to birchall

i also have other trading options such as curnow, hibberd, puopolo, lynch

thoughts

sounds good. I would consider fisher over Birchall though- no more byes left and has, from memory, a similar if not superior average.

Pitt should go- anyone from port adelaide gets first dropping priority :P

jayden pitt (fre) not pittard (port)

anyways one more question.

what to do with sandi

ive got cover with bailey and smith (cox has bye, RIDING pine)

[Ziplock]

hey zip thinking of getting in callinan this week to free up cash next week

currently on 40,100 left and 9 trades

thinking of going

pitt to callinan
lower to birchall

i also have other trading options such as curnow, hibberd, puopolo, lynch

thoughts

sounds good. I would consider fisher over Birchall though- no more byes left and has, from memory, a similar if not superior average.

Pitt should go- anyone from port adelaide gets first dropping priority :P

jayden pitt (fre) not pittard (port)

anyways one more question.

what to do with sandi

ive got cover with bailey and smith (cox has bye, RIDING pine)

*facepalm* my bad. Looks like you might as well- seems doubtful he'll get more games, cut off the deadweight. Doesn't really change my answer.

Unless you're in elim/ running close to first place and overall, I would just hold. Cox + Smith will have their byes over and done with, bailey should provide adequate 3rd ruck cover till sandi returns.

and urrrg- very punny.

[Alka]

Simple one (hopefully) from me this week.
Who to start: Hibberd or Jacobs.

[Ziplock]

Simple one (hopefully) from me this week.
Who to start: Hibberd or Jacobs.

jacobs vs brisbane is a far better prospect that hibberd vs geelong.