Final Forward

Started by patt-os, June 29, 2011, 01:15:49 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Fyfe or O'Keefe for the last spot in my forwardline?

Fyfe
13 (52%)
O'Keefe
12 (48%)

Total Members Voted: 1

patt-os

Fyfe or O'Keefe last forward line spot, both have bye in multi-bye round

gerco

Without knowing anything about your team, I'll assume you are going for league, so lets break this down Dr Jack style...

Fyfe (13 games, 98.92ppg,7 sub 100 scores (4 sub 100 scores in last 5 games), 2x120 scores, high score of 137)

Finals Games
21-Carlton (H)
22-North Melbourne (A)
23-Collingwood (H)
24-Western Bulldogs (A)

Dominated finals opponents North Melbourne (137) and Western Bulldogs (107) earlier in the year. However, he is playing Carlton and Collingwood (42 last year) in two very important games; I can see this causing him to score sub 100. 

ROK (13 games, 96ppg, 5 sub 100 scores (2 sub 100 scores in last 8 games), no 120+ scores, high score of 119)

Finals Games
21- Richmond (A)
22- Saint Kilda (ANZ Stadium)
23- Geelong (A)
24- Brisbane (H)

Stats so that ROK is more Brisbane at home in GF is great but the Cats at Skilled is a deal breaker IMO especially as he scored 68 in Round 4 versus them and averages 74.92 over 13 games all time v the Cats.

IMO go ROK; both Fyfe and ROK have hard opponents in PF week but ROK has an easier opponent in round 21 and GF week; the two point differential in average is nothing and he is more seems to be more consistent.

patt-os

Thanks gerco,

I am going for the league win and you make a very good point, thanks for the stats i reckon i will go ROK

Dizzy

Go Pav after bye, consistent scores, plus the odd 130