McIntosh trade talk

[Jas 13]

Bate and Dunn from Melbourne should be up for grabs!

[roo boys!]

Probably a little harsh towards Ivan Maric, he was a star last year, but struggled with injuries this year. But yeah, the rest are very ordinary.

I have also heard that Bernie Vince may head to Essendon next year, maybe it could then lead to a three way trade.

1. North gives Adelaide HMac.
2. Adelaide gives Vince to Essendon
3. North gets ???? from Essendon.

Through in a few draft picks here and there and I reckon this could work out great for everyone.

I suppose we could just take Jobe... :P

Nah, but I don't think we really need anyone from Essendon.

Bate and Dunn from Melbourne should be up for grabs!

Bate = ranga
Dunn = hitler moustache

:-\

But seriously, I would consider them. And perhaps a draft pick.

[c4v3m4n]

Bate and Dunn from Melbourne should be up for grabs!

I don't think there's anything we could give for them as Melbourne's rucking department is pretty solid atm.

[North Melbournes Finest]

Why would anyone want Bate? His playing still is as ugly as the looks he brings. Along with Dunn who is pretty bad and has bad relationship with Harvey.

[c4v3m4n]

http://www.heraldsun.com.au/sport/afl/roo-ruckman-hamish-mcintosh-going-nowhere/story-e6frf9io-1226087741141

[North Melbournes Finest]

Damien Barrett just made mention that Richmond are going to push hard for Hamish, and we've expressed that we won't trade him, but who knows if the right trade came up...

Realistically what would it take for us to do a deal with them? I just don't see many good options on their list for us.

[Holz]

Damien Barrett just made mention that Richmond are going to push hard for Hamish, and we've expressed that we won't trade him, but who knows if the right trade came up...

Realistically what would it take for us to do a deal with them? I just don't see many good options on their list for us.

it would have to be martin, lids or voldt and they wont give any of them up.

wow didnt realise deledio was the young would happy give up hmac and number 3 draft pick hansen for him.

[Windigo]

I didn't need Barrett to tell me that Richmond need a ruckmen & that we would pursue H-Mac.

All you Roo supporters stop having delirious ambitions of getting Deledio, Martin ETC. It won't happen! :P

[North Melbournes Finest]

I didn't need Barrett to tell me that Richmond need a ruckmen & that we would pursue H-Mac.

All you Roo supporters stop having delirious ambitions of getting Deledio, Martin ETC. It won't happen! :P

I never thought we could get Martin, but then you look at the rest of Tigers list and it's pretty much shower?

They've got either, untouchable young stars - Deledio/Vickery/Cotchin/Riewoldt/Martin, and then they have a surplus of duds...

[Windigo]

Haha. We have a FEW good players...... ::)

[North Melbournes Finest]

Haha. We have a FEW good players...... ::)

Riddle some off.

[Windigo]

Ahem.......:

THE BIG 3:

Cotchin
Martin
Deledio

EMERGING TALENT:

Rance, (Think he is coming along nicely.)
J.Riewoldt ( I don't think he is a star....YET!)
Vickery-Starting to prove why he was selected so high in the draft, but he ain't a dominate ruck men, more of a FWD.
Nahas~ Stepping up in 2011

The Old Fossils:

S.Tuck, Just cannot get games with Hardwick.
Newman, great leader but not up there with the greats.

A few duds....... :(

Probably missed some players that deserve to go in emerging talent. Perhaps someone else can add to that.

[North Melbournes Finest]

Exactly everyone I mentioned, you mentioned. Except Rance and Nahas are players we just don't need.

[Windigo]

But still, Richmond will try & get H-Mac to Richmond. That's a near certainty.

[North Melbournes Finest]

But still, Richmond will try & get H-Mac to Richmond. That's a near certainty.

But what for is the question! ANSWER IT!