defender downgrade

[bob321]

Looking to offload heppel this week for cash.
Who has more chance of continuing to get games?
Lisle from the hawks or golby from the lions

[R.Griffen]

don't downgrade Heppell upgrade him

[the raven]

don't downgrade Heppell upgrade him

I agree, if you got cash then use it to bring in a premium defender, maybe shaw with no more byes.

[Talisman]

Would've thought with Schoenmakers & Franklin to come back in (+ with Gibson, Hale and Bailey all playing, & Renouf potentially coming back in soon) that Lisle's JS will be very suspect - and with the Hawks challenging for a top 4 spot, it's less likely that they'll be playing too many kids (esp. KPP kids) - they've already got Savage, Shiels, Poupolo, Breust, Suckling, Whitecross & I.Smith.

Golby, on the other hand, is a running defender in a struggling team (the Lions), who must continue to play the kids, & have other running defenders like Adcock & Drummond in & out injured... I'd be suggesting that whilst he might not score a bucket load, that Golby's JS should be pretty could as a d9/d10 - purely for cover if there's a spate of injuries in your defence - and should comfortably be better than Lisle's. IMO.

[bob321]

Golby, on the other hand, is a running defender in a struggling team (the Lions), who must continue to play the kids, & have other running defenders like Adcock & Drummond in & out injured... I'd be suggesting that whilst he might not score a bucket load, that Golby's JS should be pretty could as a d9/d10 - purely for cover if there's a spate of injuries in your defence - and should comfortably be better than Lisle's. IMO.

sounds like he might be the better option as yes this will be purely for cover in the future if puop/stanley/jacobs are all not playing/covering outs already. hibberd will replace heppel as my 7th def until after the hawks bye when i will bring in suckling.