Final Defender

[Spooners]

Already have Gibbs and Murphy

Cheers

[Chelskiman]

Already have Gibbs and Murphy

Cheers

It's a pretty easy decision then.  Shaw.

[Spooners]

Scotland's scores against the teams he plays in the remainder of the season are miles better than Shaw's equivalent.

Scotland is also averaging more AND scores more on a consistent basis

Scotland won't get tagged and Carlton's defence get more possessions than Collingwood's

Even with Carlton's round 23 bye, there is no guarantee Shaw won't be rested and the 40 or so points i'll lose by playing a rookie in Carlton's bye, I could easily lose in just 1 game where Shaw has a tag

There are a tonne of positives for Shaw but its far from an easy decision

[jl1814]

sounds like u've already made up your mind on who u want

[Spooners]

sounds like u've already made up your mind on who u want

I think I've ruled out Carrazzo but I havent made up my mind. Shaw can have huge games, if he doesnt get rested then its a massive bonus. Its just interesting to see how a player who would average in the mid to low 80s were it not for 3 huge games is being unanimously chosen over a player who consistently scores 95+ on the basis that I'll have to play 1 more rookie in Round 23

[jl1814]

i think people would go shaw since he doesn't have any byes left - most after a league win would choose him

it sounds like you are going for overall - in which case, i'd say go scotland