Mitchell or Ablett???

[Carlton123]

I don't know who to trade for Selwood and it's killing me!

Ablett has no more byes but is quite inconsistent
Mitchell is 50k cheaper but can't take a tag
Shiels is a youngster but has some huge scores

My midfield at the moment is:
Boyd, Pendles, Swan, Bartel, S.Thompson and Selwood

I don't want Murphy because of his round 23 bye as i'm going for a league win.

Please Help!!!!!!

[Windigo]

I'm getting both.  ;)

Mundy>GAJ & Joell>Mitchell

Mitchy has 9 tons from 11 games.

Shiels has some monster scores and looks to go on with it......

Tough call, go with your gut. IMO you won't lose much with any pick.

[Andrew]

I've been agonising over the same 2 choices myself and am 99% sure I'll be getting Ablett tomorrow as his no byes beats having Mitchell along with Suckling & Franklin for the Hawks bye. See this thread I started with a poll as to who the best replacement is - Ablett even beat Boyd: http://www.fanfooty.com.au/forum/index.php/topic,38727.0.html

Hope that helps.

[Windigo]

Well if you cannot get both, get GAJ. No more byes, no worries.  8)

[Holz]

get gaj unless you could use the money. Im leaning towards mitchell as it means i can get syliva aswell and get rid of knights. If this option wasnt aviable than gaz easy, he couldvery easily  finish the year as the number 1 averaging player.

[Andrew]

get gaj unless you could use the money. Im leaning towards mitchell as it means i can get syliva aswell and get rid of knights. If this option wasnt aviable than gaz easy, he couldvery easily  finish the year as the number 1 averaging player.

Yes I think getting a bottomed out Sylvia is crucial for those who don't have him, thankfully I've got enough to cash to get Ablett now and Sylvia next week.

[Carlton123]

Thanks Andrew, think i'll go with Gaz.

Also i have both Max Bailey and Max Gawn to replae Zac Smith, which one should I play on field?
Pretty sure i'll go with Bailey.

[Windigo]

Thanks Andrew,

Any time.  ;) (My name is also Andrew. :P)

[Andrew]

Thanks Andrew, think i'll go with Gaz.

Also i have both Max Bailey and Max Gawn to replae Zac Smith, which one should I play on field?
Pretty sure i'll go with Bailey.

No worries, I'm going Gaz also along with a majority of the competition (looking at Assistant Coach stats) so if we fall, we all fall! On your other problem, start Bailey for sure.

Thanks Andrew,

Any time.  ;) (My name is also Andrew. :P)

Top bloke   :P

[Windigo]

Thanks Andrew,


    Any time.  ;) (My name is also Andrew. :P)


Top bloke   :P

Do you have a brother called Nathan??

I know 3 people whose names is Andrew and all their brothers are called Nathan, mine included. Very weird.

[Andrew]

Thanks Andrew,


    Any time.  ;) (My name is also Andrew. :P)


Top bloke   :P

Do you have a brother called Nathan??

I know 3 people whose names is Andrew and all their brothers are called Nathan, mine included. Very weird.

Nope!