Too many Saints ?

Started by jimmyha, June 15, 2009, 10:19:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

jimmyha

Hey guys,

I really want to try and get Montagna into my midfield
but I already have Dal Santo, Riewoldt, Goddard and Gilbert..

Is having 5 saints in the team too much ?  ???

bjrouse

no, while you at it get hayes as well
I have all the 4 you mentioned plus Ball and 5 Cats
As long as they score well who cares how many you have

Al

Well the thing is if the Saints have an off day your score will suffer substantially.

The Saints draw is a bit harder second half of the year so maybe they will find things a little tougher. I still think that it won't really matter, but maybe don't expect their averages to rise, rather drop a few points a week.

I would get him if I were you, as he will still be better than most.

jameswilson

I don't think it would really matter seeing as st.kilda have the easiest draw i've ever seen.

Dal Santo plays well when st.kilda plays well hes not a game breaker imo.
Mantag would be a really good pick up.
I think hes under priced

antman

#4
I have those 5 in my teams and I'm all :).

Hawks_1976

If you can afford him without making too much sacrifice elsewhere then get him. His form has been consistent and should fluctuate too much.

toodledock

Quote from: Al on June 16, 2009, 06:59:55 AM
Well the thing is if the Saints have an off day your score will suffer substantially.

The Saints draw is a bit harder second half of the year so maybe they will find things a little tougher. I still think that it won't really matter, but maybe don't expect their averages to rise, rather drop a few points a week.

I would get him if I were you, as he will still be better than most.

this, this is why my rule is no more than 3 of any team bar geelong

hodge
buddy
tuck

3 epic EPIC EPIC EPIC fails this year in SC and I've had them all

BradStar

some people have so much brisbane and geelong  midfielders

Cutty

if the Midfield of a team is scoring consistantly high there is no reason why you cant have them all, its not like the brownlow where they are fighting each other for votes

BradStar

Quote from: Cutty on June 20, 2009, 06:49:28 AM
if the Midfield of a team is scoring consistantly high there is no reason why you cant have them all, its not like the brownlow where they are fighting each other for votes
thats right.

Blueboys

Quote from: toodledock on June 19, 2009, 06:24:23 AM
Quote from: Al on June 16, 2009, 06:59:55 AM
Well the thing is if the Saints have an off day your score will suffer substantially.

The Saints draw is a bit harder second half of the year so maybe they will find things a little tougher. I still think that it won't really matter, but maybe don't expect their averages to rise, rather drop a few points a week.

I would get him if I were you, as he will still be better than most.

this, this is why my rule is no more than 3 of any team bar geelong

hodge
buddy
tuck

3 epic EPIC EPIC EPIC fails this year in SC and I've had them all

and you can add the Saints to the cats too!

toodledock

I believe at least some point pinching goes on...