Whos better? Voss, Hird or Bucks?

[Maca24]

Hey guys.
Who is the best player out of these players:

J.Hird
N.Buckley
M.Voss

would like your opinion. am very curious to see results. im talking about best player nothing more.

[BradStar]

in my opinion, Voss then Hird then Bucks.
Voss is Gun.

[Maca24]

Hird was way better than voss.
Voss was in a good team and they made him look better than what he was.
Hird was versatile and he playd full forward and back line aswell as midfield. voss was only able to play midfield.

[freezer]

All very good players. I personally think Hird won more games for Essendon off his own boot than the others did at Brisbane or Collingwood.

[2Fat2Old]

Cant pick that one they are all true champs
Maybe Voss for the 3 peat

[nickyt]

3 very good players there!

[toodledock]

jesus I accidently clicked buckley but I mean Hird! Someone fix it?

This is also on facebook we're Jimmy is holding a lead too
http://apps.facebook.com/livingsocial/micro/polls/126909/results


Bucks and Voss were admittedly good but Hird had the majestic the sublime skills and the ability to single handedly win games.

I remember even in his last season I counted 3 times or more were his actions either won us the game or stopped us losing it. I would also know I have been seeing the bombers since 93 when I was 6!

[JSelwood14]

Thats my order from best to worst outa those players, all great tho.
1.Voss 
2.Hird
3.Bucks

[JSelwood14]

Voss is a star!!!!!!!!!

[heard]

cant be serious mate, tell me this poll is a joke! no challenge for hirdy mate  :P

[MiGZ]

this is ludacris....BUCKLEY by a country mile over Hird then Voss. Have a look at the man's statistics compared to the other two. He easily had the best skills out of the 3 and carried that team through their toughest times. Anyone who has read his book would agree. Voss was highly over rated, he played in a very good team in the peak of his career, no one could question his ferosity at the contest but for any other gauge of how good a player is he didn't compare at all. Hird no doubt had a footballer's brain, but wasn't the athlete buckley was, Buckley was the complete package.

look at these statistics, Buckley overwhelming...

http://www.finalsiren.com/PlayerCompare.asp?SeasonID=&PlayerName1=james+hird&PlayerName2=michael+voss&PlayerName3=&PlayerName4=&Compare=Compare&SelectedPlayers=1265%2C

[2Fat2Old]

Geez, I thought they nicknamed Bucks "FIGJAM".
We don't need others blowing his trumpet as well.
He was a decent footballer yes, but was he really that far ahead of the other two. Voss with 3 premiership rings is some serious bling to show around. I bet if you asked Bucks if he was envious of that, the answer would be a resounding YES. Maybe he still wears the 1992 premiership ring from the Port Adelaide Magpies playing days.
Now if you weren't a Pies supporter there would be a hell of a lot more credit given for your comments. Remember Bucks is a Hawks supporter by heart.

Ps The fact that your plugging his book is overwhelmingly scary. Looks to me like theres a little too much man love there. Oh yeah, stat fact, he was originally from South Australia. So as a fellow S.A. boy, I thank you for the compliment to our state. Looks to me like we only produce the best, hey.

Kind regards
Fat Man

[nas]

Acutually he was born in NT & the old man played for the Peckers.

he also has a Magery Medal to add to the Chas

[2Fat2Old]

Actually he was born in Adelaide. Moved to NT when he was 10 years old.

Brownlow Medal
1st - 2003 (3 way tie)
2nd - 1997
3rd - 1999 (equal)
5th - 1996 (equal), 2000 (equal)

Australian Football League
Norm Smith Medal 2002
Rising Star Award 1993

Collingwood Football Club
Best & Fairest 1994 (equal), 1996, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2003
RT Rush Trophy 1997
JJ Joyce Trophy 2001

Collingwood Team Of The Century
Club captain 1999-2007

Brisbane Bears Football Club
2nd Best & Fairest 1993
Representative Honours

All-Australian Team 1996, 1997, 1998, 2001
All-Australian Team vice-captain 1999, 2000, 2003
International Rules Series 1998 (captain)
Alex Jesaulenko Medal 1997
Allies captain 1997

South Australian National Football League
Magarey Medal 1992
Jack Oatey Medal (Grand Final B.O.G.) 1992
Port Adelaide Football Club best & fairest 1992

Premierships
SANFL 1992 (Port Adelaide Football Club)

[nas]

Ah well knew he had something to do with NT