Which DPP?

Started by LaHug, June 10, 2011, 03:13:10 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which one do I get? (Read below before voting)

I. Smith
3 (20%)
Callinan
3 (20%)
J.Tippett
8 (53.3%)
Someone else (please say who and why)
1 (6.7%)

Total Members Voted: 1

LaHug

Quote from: PowerBug on June 10, 2011, 05:59:16 PM
Chappy can be your 6th mid. It's fine.
But I don't have Swan yet and was gonna get him after the bye......

Master Q

J.Tipp  ;)

Don't wanna let you down  :-X

LaHug

Thanks for the responses, everyone. Tippett it is!

Windigo

I.Smith must have gone on vacation somewhere. I tip the Bahamas.  8)

LaHug

Just realised I could go Duigan or Stanley --> Howard/Nicholson and play Darling instead. IS THAT A BETTER MOVE?!? AAAAAAGGHH!

LaHug

PLEASE RESPOND! What would be the points lost in playing Darling over Zac Smith?!

Windigo

Maybe 30.

Darling is good for a 60-70.

Z.Smith on recent form. 80+

LaHug

So, Windigo, would you downgrade Duigan and play Darling, or downgrade Darling and play Zac Smith? Keeping in mind that downgrading Darling would be to a non-playing rookie but downgrading Duigan would be to a playing rookie.

Windigo

Hang on a minute.

Darling & Smith play different positions. Is there something I'm missing here.  :P

LaHug

DPP. I'd be downgrading Darling to Jippett, playing Petrie forward and playing Smith in the rucks.

Windigo

Oh wow, you have Petrie in the rucks with Cox. And Z.Smith is scoring tons on the bench...I see.

I would get J.Tippett. Who cares if he is a rookie. Lobbe, from all accounts really stinks.......

So, Darling>Tippett & swap Petrie into FWDS. Play Z.Smith & Cox like everyone else is.

Then if you have a trade to burn....Upgrade Duigan>Scotland

LaHug

I already have a complete backline... But yeah, that was my original thought.
Unless someone talks me out of it in the next few minutes, I guess that's what I'll go with.

Windigo

QuoteI already have a complete backline

Okay.  :)