Stark Raving Mad

[Windigo]

My plan was this:

Sandi>J.Tippet & Stanley>Scotland

But against my saner side of my mind I have been entertaining the notion of this:

Sandi>J.Tippet & BOAK>J.Selwood

Next Week:

Stanley>Scotland

Week After:

Puopolo/Lower/Jacobs>SHAW?

As much as I like Boak.......Is this ludicrous?

MIDS: Swan, Boyd, Selwood, Redden, Mundy & A.Swalllow

THOUGHTS?

Get Murphy instead and thus not get Scotland or other mid option.....Or keep Boak and do my original trade

10 trades and team complete after that^^^^

[Madsnake]

Don't get scotland because then i can get him  ;)

and don't get rid of your beloved boaky cakes, he's your pride and joy.

[Windigo]

Just a thought.

[Montag]

to be honest i like the mids trade
scotland isnt selling it for me. he has been consistently good but he is old and wearing out. all it will take is one down week and he will be cheap as chips

selwood and murphy will finish top 5 mids need to get in.
for me selwood just over murphy. he is in brownlow form and looks great consistently. murphy with judd, gibbs, robinson, scotland, ellard ect. he might struggle some weeks. selwood by a pigs pubic hair

[Windigo]

Hm, as much as I like Boak and he would be a gun at another club.......

Selwood is the best DT'er going around if it wasn't for that 20 odd first match......

[Memphistopheles]

Selwood over Boak

Scotland for Stanley and Shaw for Lower all sound like great moves.

[Windigo]

Selwood over Boak

Scotland for Stanley and Shaw for Lower all sound like great moves.

Only thing is I lose Sandi who is out for 5 weeks.  ;)

[JBs-Hawks]

Just went Boak > Ablett

Never again will i get a port prem in my team

[Windigo]

Great player but in PORt side.

Joel Selwood picked two places behind Boak welcome.

[Fireballz]

I assume you're going for overall and not league with the carlton bye during finals?
If option 2 results in you having Scotland AND Selwood after next week, then that looks like a winner to me.

[PowerBug]

Hold Boaky. get Scotland.

[Andrew]

Hold Boaky. get Scotland.

+1 but if your team is too negatively affected by Boak's bye (such as it'll cost you eliminator) it's probably a good week to move him on. Also keep in mind DT league final byes - you're doing quite well at the moment without players copping them. It makes getting Enright all the harder to stomach.

[Chelskiman]

Boak is Port's best player, but he is only going to get you 90-100 points.  Selwwod is going to get you, on average, 105-120 points.  Go Boak to Selwood, and don't look back.

[Windigo]

Fairly confident I'll miss the league match with Geelong. I'm not getting Enright.

Shaw, Selwood & Scotland

Selwood=this week
Scotland=next week
Shaw=week after

With boak out I'm starting Prestia & Hibberd. If I get Selwood I'll only start one of them and have a full team minus swan.

Boak is Port's best player, but he is only going to get you 90-100 points.

For sure, I was hoping this year Boak would turn into a 100+ player. He certainly has it in him. But I never expected Port to be so bad this year.

Once again in a good team Boak would get 100 easily with a bit of help.

Do I get Murphy instead? Don't get Scotland & get like Shaw & Deledio?

But then the Multi-Bye would have me flowered really....

[Fireballz]

Scotland and Deledio! Shaw's a hack.