Trade out Zac Smith?

[North Melbournes Finest]

Has Zac Smith bottomed out, should I trade him for Joel Tippett and use the MPP with Petrie,

I'm thinking

Zac Smith to Joel Tippett
and
Mitch Wallis to Ryan Okeefe

That then gives me MPP and
Okeefe and Mzungu
Okeefe and Isaac Smith
Drew Petrie and Joel Tippett

Also means with Dane Swan missing next two weeks I won't have to use a rookie in the mids for the next two weeks and after the two weeks I can swap Okeefe to the forward line and pick up another mid.

I'll post my team later, I'm at school at the moment.

[gracey89]

Yer if we could see your team it would help! Zac smith is almost good for bench cover atleast until your 2 starters have had there byes!

[charliesheen]

post your team mate.

Mitch Wallis trade seems a bit silly ^^

[Torress]

zac smth trade out now???  hell no!!! BE of 23 this week he will go over 400k no doubts! hold off mate!
smith will be my cash cow for finals, in the meantime he will cover cox and sandi's bye/ sandi's toe lol!!

[Fletch74]

zac smth trade out now???  hell no!!! BE of 1 this week he will go over 400k no doubts! hold off mate!
smith will be my cash cow for finals, in the meantime he will cover cox and sandi's bye/ sandi's toe lol!!

+1

[sj9177]

Hes looking better and better, great cover for Sandi and Cox and will be 400k year end, crazy trade imho

[pothead]

I would definately keep smith he is getting great scores and hasnt even reached his full price.

[PICCOLLO]

Petrie a keeper.  Sell smithy if next week or when sandi back.

[swedishhmafia]

Mate, crazy idea! Keep him until Sandi is back to either trade up to him or to use as cover. He'll still be pumping out 100s while he is still number 1 ruck. I'll be keeping him as ruck cover for Sandi and Cox and my 4th ruck will be J.Tippett/Petrie

[almax]

Keep him a bit longer, im looking to use him to trade up to Cox, but in the meantime he is filling in for Sandy nicely.

[enzedder]

Keep him a bit longer, im looking to use him to trade up to Cox, but in the meantime he is filling in for Sandy nicely.

This is what I have decided also.

[Maca24]

You dont trade anyone who is coming off two 115+ scores.

[Ringo]

I do not have Sandi but am holding Smith to Round 16 after Eagles 2nd bye.  Am watching him closely for peaking but showing no signs at the moment. Trade for round 16 will be Smith to Tippet to utilise Petrie/Tippett DPP when required.

[dominic17]

my rucks are cox - ryder (smith, bailey)

since bailey has been playing and doing well i think ill downgrade ryder to tippet and have mmp for petrie in the forwards if needed. then once sandi comes back ill upgrade smith to him and have petrie or bailey for cover. i think by the time sandi is back smith will reach his top price.

[North Melbournes Finest]