Lockyer or Newman

[sobeyyy]

Who do u think is a better trade.

Raines for Lockyer,
Or
Raines for Newman

Thoughts??

[Prospector_1]

Newman - no pies. And Rawlings has kept Newman while dumping Bowden.

[yogibbear]

Lockyer. Only pie you want in your team cause he doesn't play like a pie.

[blake2412]

Newman. He is a supercoach gun.

[Prospector_1]

Agreed Yogi, Lockyer could be considered here. Also, as far as pies go, Swan could be considered - but only in DT.

[Crows 09 PREMIERS]

I reckon GET Lockyer he is a bit more costinent than Newman i have both but by far lockyer is better in DT
Lockyer most times play mid so he gets heaps of balls  GET HIM

[penskifile]

id get lockyer, he is capable of a bigger scoring game than newman. he can get forward more and kick goals

[tony73]

Oi Ive got Swan in SC and am mighty pleased so far!

[hibbo]

id get lockyer, he is capable of a bigger scoring game than newman. he can get forward more and kick goals

Scores over 100 this year:
Lockyer- 104, 146, 150, 122
Newman- 105, 107, 111, 115, 114, 101, 121, 117

While Lockyer can pull a big score, Newman consistently tons up and usually scores bigger then Lockyer. So I'd get Newman.

[nas]

I would also have to go with Newman

[penskifile]

id get lockyer, he is capable of a bigger scoring game than newman. he can get forward more and kick goals

Scores over 100 this year:
Lockyer- 104, 146, 150, 122
Newman- 105, 107, 111, 115, 114, 101, 121, 117

While Lockyer can pull a big score, Newman consistently tons up and usually scores bigger then Lockyer. So I'd get Newman.

Lockyer ave 103, newman 101, not including a 70 from newman last week. lockyer also has 4 scores in the 90's. i just personally like the guys capable of going big!

[2Fat2Old]

Only thing to worry about is if one does a mischief, cause both are guns :-\

[hibbo]

id get lockyer, he is capable of a bigger scoring game than newman. he can get forward more and kick goals

Scores over 100 this year:
Lockyer- 104, 146, 150, 122
Newman- 105, 107, 111, 115, 114, 101, 121, 117

While Lockyer can pull a big score, Newman consistently tons up and usually scores bigger then Lockyer. So I'd get Newman.

Lockyer ave 103, newman 101, not including a 70 from newman last week. lockyer also has 4 scores in the 90's. i just personally like the guys capable of going big!

Yep fair call, so it seems Newman for consistency and Lockyer for the bigger scores. Still, I'm leaning to Newman.