Callinan vs I. Smith

Started by hally25547, June 03, 2011, 11:14:38 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who?

Callinan
7 (70%)
I Smith
3 (30%)

Total Members Voted: 1

hally25547

I need the cash and the DPP link. So who should i get??

Callinan - I think once he gets in the team he will stay in the team. Hasn't played yet so its risky
Smith - He has scored OK in his two games. Can't break into the Hawks team even with Bateman going down.

Confused - HELP ME!!!

chaosAD

I think you answered your own question mate, i would go Callinan only because smith has already had to pretty good games and hasn't been named since.
If Smith was named this week i wouls of gone him but he's not so go Callinan and get the extra cash !

PowerBug

Quote from: chaosAD on June 03, 2011, 11:17:04 AM
I think you answered your own question mate, i would go Callinan only because smith has already had to pretty good games and hasn't been named since.
If Smith was named this week i wouls of gone him but he's not so go Callinan and get the extra cash !

+1

Fenno

Im thinking of going smith because im probably going to want both eventually anyway so may aswell get the bloke who has already played 2 games. That was have more games to pick up Callinan

Slap


Windigo

Matera>I.Smith & Darling>Goodes

Then next week: Lower>Deledio.

I would have 5 hawks players....

thatguy

Quote from: Windigo on June 03, 2011, 02:59:13 PM
Matera>I.Smith & Darling>Goodes

Then next week: Lower>Deledio.

I would have 5 hawks players....

could hurt round 17!

Windigo

Suckling, Puopolo, Smith, Bailey & Franklin

Worth getting Callinan?

I need to get my team strong in the next two weeks. Getting Goodes is paramount.