Harris Vs Swallow

Started by ben1994, May 30, 2011, 12:03:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

ben1994

Hi all.

Hope your weekend supercoaching was good and you all got a win.

I am thinking of getting in Selwood or Mundy for Harris or Swallow.

What are your guys thoughts??

cortez

Swallow is still scoring well. Harris had a dud score and his be has gone up so I'd be trading Harris.

scotty_222

i reckon this is a tough one
harris is a mature ager tougher body. has just come back from injury
had a bad game this week but everyweek i think he has the potential
to out score swallow. swallow might begin to be rested as the weeks
roll on. its a tough call but seeing as harris now has a bigger be
people will get rid of him.
i reckon if u have libba get him out first
harris might come back for a good game this week.

cortez

Swallow is the most developed 18 i think I've seen. Can't see him dropping off imo.

PiggyPommy

Id toss a coin for whoever to trade out and id get Selwood in.

Swallow12

Trade swallow, harris perm bench cover later on

tor01doc

I am trading in with future byes in mind...so Freo, Swans, Crows, GC, Melb, Adel for me...GAJ?

scotty_222

guy has spoken about giving his rookies time off in the coming weeks.
harris has just had 2 weeks off.
its a toughie

twinkle

I traded out Harris and kept Swallow - reckon he is a gun in the making whereas Harris is OK and will continue to be just OK. imo