Best Defender Money can buy>??

[Chopps]

want to know what the best defender is & why money is not a factor, i am thinking Scotland very consistent

current line up
Adcock, Gibbs, Goddard, Deledio, Gram, Heppel, Stanley, <lower, Poupolo, Jacobs>

[Sleeken]

I'd go Shaw or Suckling, who have both been very consistent. Shaw rebounds from defense, runs up the ground a fair bit.

I wouldn't want 2 from Carlton because of the rd 23 bye but if that doesn't bother you...

[LF]

i was looking at scotland but having him and gibbs together with carltons bye in round 23 i`ve decide to look elsewhere.

[Chopps]

i was thinking that but he is Dpp just slide him to the mids for cover should be fine only 2 out

[Sleeken]

If you have no Carlton mids then go for it!

Still, on personal preference (and price) I'd take Shaw.

[Chopps]

really why?

also i'd have to wait on shaw as i have pendles and swan

[Wes Mantooth]

really why?

also i'd have to wait on shaw as i have pendles and swan

shaw has been gunning it. is there any hurry to get him - there's only a couple of round before col bye

[Sleeken]

really why?

also i'd have to wait on shaw as i have pendles and swan

shaw has been gunning it. is there any hurry to get him - there's only a couple of round before col bye

This and he's 20k cheaper, should average the same. Also, I have a tendancy against selecting two players from the same team in the same line in case their team get belted, which doesn't really hold much ground in AFL (many years of fantasy premierleague).

[Wes Mantooth]

really why?

also i'd have to wait on shaw as i have pendles and swan

shaw has been gunning it. is there any hurry to get him - there's only a couple of round before col bye

This and he's 20k cheaper, should average the same. Also, I have a tendancy against selecting two players from the same team in the same line in case their team get belted, which doesn't really hold much ground in AFL (many years of fantasy premierleague).

yeah but this year having too many of one team can get you in trouble with a bye and one injury. its good practice so it does hold sway IMO

[Chopps]

I would argue if done right 2 from one line is worth it set you apart as others dont want to risk it, I started pendles and swan seems to. Be goin well 110 +  Averages

My argument to Gibbs & Scotland both mpp so I can change 1 to mids effectively having one on each line by rd23 plan is Heppel is my 8 th back, this is realistic as apart from lti's I would say my team is complete with this double only rookie playing (not covering) byes is Heppel

[Wes Mantooth]

i have murphy, so this would be one too many out for me

[Footy God]

IMO Gram has to go.

[jvalles]

I called Birchall last week and I still stand by it!  I'd have got him except I want to finish my midfield this week and needed to downgrade last week.