Stanley

Started by FLOPITOUT1, May 29, 2011, 12:46:11 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What did you do with Stanley

Traded him oops :(
Kept him didnt play him
Kept him and played him
Dont have him :(

FLOPITOUT1

Quote from: Bluke on May 29, 2011, 01:08:46 PM
Yea I think Duigan is finally going to get the axe this week so I can bring in Chapman

Although I just know that he will crank out a 90 or something next week lol.

Duigan -> Delaney

or

Duigan -> Hunt

Both not the best trades but there arnt a lot of other options down back. And Hunt is only 87k and could bring his avg up a bit if they start playing him forward.

Gotta have a think about Delaney JS before I commit to him though.
Gonna be hard finding downgrade targets now in the backs i like the look of Delaney

Bluke

Well thats not a real big drama, Callinan will be back soon as well. So just cull matera before he drops in value and then cull tapscott to callinan before tappy can play a game and drop again.

Then use the money to turn Harris in to a gun...

So do I, provided he holds his spot. I think he will but couldnt find any info on the Grima injury? Any ideas how long he is out for?

Nails

Christian Howard (debuts for the dogs) this week could be an option in the back.

Some guy on here said they had him since rd1 so I'm guessing he must be able to do something. I'll be keeping my ears on him whilst listening to the broadcast this arvo.

Bluke

Thanks for the heads up Nails

FLOPITOUT1

Quote from: Bluke on May 29, 2011, 01:23:14 PM
Well thats not a real big drama, Callinan will be back soon as well. So just cull matera before he drops in value and then cull tapscott to callinan before tappy can play a game and drop again.

Then use the money to turn Harris in to a gun...

So do I, provided he holds his spot. I think he will but couldnt find any info on the Grima injury? Any ideas how long he is out for?
Yeah true. I think Grima out for another 4 to 6 weeks with broken finger but not sure about the timeframe

Dunham29


Windigo

Kept him and played him over Puo.

It was no-brainer.

Great consistency. I expected him to get about 60-70. So 98 is a great.  ;)

Wes Mantooth

Gun kid, good JS and will be a keeper as my reserve back.

bigsy

yeah i reckon ill keep him as my seventh back rather than wasting a trade on an unreliable backman

FLOPITOUT1

Quote from: bigsy on May 29, 2011, 02:28:28 PM
yeah i reckon ill keep him as my seventh back rather than wasting a trade on an unreliable backman
+ 1

LaHug

I already have 7 backs (unless I keep Stanley instead of Heppell - which I probably won't do) so I'll just wait til Stanley tops out and take advantage of the huge amount of cash!

FLOPITOUT1

Che Ching. Not planning on any LTI's in your backline

LaHug

Quote from: FLOPITOUT1 on May 29, 2011, 03:34:54 PM
Che Ching. Not planning on any LTI's in your backline
I have Jacobs as MPP cover.
But even if I kept Stanley, I'd probably trade out whoever gets injured for a new premium, so I still see no reason to keep him.

If you have an LTI, you don't bring on a rookie as your new starter, you trade the injured player for a new premium!

FLOPITOUT1

#28
Quote from: LaHug on May 29, 2011, 03:42:58 PM
Quote from: FLOPITOUT1 on May 29, 2011, 03:34:54 PM
Che Ching. Not planning on any LTI's in your backline
I have Jacobs as MPP cover.
But even if I kept Stanley, I'd probably trade out whoever gets injured for a new premium, so I still see no reason to keep him.

If you have an LTI, you don't bring on a rookie as your new starter, you trade the injured player for a new premium!
Ok not an LTI a 4 week injury. Stanley imo is a keeper and i would be happy to start him. I have Jacobs,Puopolo and Stanley as my benchies not wasting anymore trades in my backline. Id like to see exactly who you would bring in as a premium to get rid of a premium there are b.u.gger all. My backline  Adcock,Shaw,Enright,Goddard,Deledio,Gibbs,Heppell,Stanley,Jacobs,Puopolo. I wouldnt be relying on Jacobs all year thats for sure. Your opinion against mine ay good luck hope you put the cash to good work, if im getting rid of anyone it's pup.

LaHug

Quote from: FLOPITOUT1 on May 29, 2011, 05:28:34 PM
Quote from: LaHug on May 29, 2011, 03:42:58 PM
Quote from: FLOPITOUT1 on May 29, 2011, 03:34:54 PM
Che Ching. Not planning on any LTI's in your backline
I have Jacobs as MPP cover.
But even if I kept Stanley, I'd probably trade out whoever gets injured for a new premium, so I still see no reason to keep him.

If you have an LTI, you don't bring on a rookie as your new starter, you trade the injured player for a new premium!
Ok not an LTI a 4 week injury. Stanley imo is a keeper and i would be happy to start him. I have Jacobs,Puopolo and Stanley as my benchies not wasting anymore trades in my backline. Id like to see exactly who you would bring in as a premium to get rid of a premium there are b.u.gger all. My backline  Adcock,Shaw,Enright,Goddard,Deledio,Gibbs,Heppell,Stanley,Jacobs,Puopolo. I wouldnt be relying on Jacobs all year thats for sure. Your opinion against mine ay good luck hope you put the cash to good work, if im getting rid of anyone it's pup.
You're saying I should keep a cash cow and all that money on the bench for the 10 or so extra points I'd get each week IF someone gets injured for a few games but not long enough to warrant trading out? That sounds like a lot of sacrifice for very little gain in the case of an unlikely situation.