Okay, my last Sandi post... bring Petrie in to fwd's and swap or trade Sandi...

Started by Possumo, May 27, 2011, 07:59:15 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

The Sandi question

Bench Sandi, trade Matera to Petrie, swap with Tippett and use as cover in fwd's/rucks
3 (42.9%)
Trade Sandi to someone...
4 (57.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Possumo

Okay, I'll make it easier this time :) Yes or no? 13 trades left, and league only, so Nic Nat's and S. Jacobs bye's aren't a concern...

Edit: I have to admit I am keen on going Petrie and keeping Sandi is looking like the best option. BUT if I go Jacobs/Nic Nat/Smith, I can afford to go Tapscott > Chapman next week...

If I get Petrie in the forwards and keep Sandi, I will only have 2-3 k left...  it does seem like a bit of a sideways trade too... as Petrie won't even be playing for me for most of the season... having Chapman next week will probably give me a lot more points...

Bluke

Petrie is the best option. Gives you added flexability incase another ruck goes down.

Possumo

Quote from: Bluke on May 27, 2011, 08:06:46 PM
Petrie is the best option. Gives you added flexability incase another ruck goes down.

True, but until Sandi comes back I won't have any cover and will be relying on him to play... I just feel that having Sandi on the bench is a lot of money I could be using, especially when there is doubt about when he will return... if I was going to trade Sandi out, my trade him target is probably going to be a keeper for the rest of the season... the extra money will allow me to get a premium straight off the bat next week, instead of requiring another downgrade trade... so even if I do trade Sandi back in, I'll be in the same position by then in terms of trades. Trading in Petrie purely to have bench cover/replace Sandi's scoring isn't probably that important in my forward line...

Arghhh this is painful :(