Big Problem Possibly other are facing.

Started by Holz, May 27, 2011, 06:56:30 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Option

Matera to I.Smith and Darling to Chappy
5 (35.7%)
Matera to Callinan and Darling to Chappy
1 (7.1%)
Matera to Lynch and Knights to Chappy
7 (50%)
Matera to Breust and Darling to Chappy
1 (7.1%)

Total Members Voted: 0

Holz

I really want to get in chapy this week i feel he is in for a huge one against GC asnd this will be his cheapest all season.
I have decided to get rid or darling for him and i need an additional 93k to make the trade.

The only guys i have left to move are stanley, harris and matera. Harris is not going and there are no good options i can think of for stanley as i alreadh have hibberrd, pup, jacobs.

So im pretty sure its matera who needs to go, i originally wanted to bring in lynch but i need to get a guy who is under 100k, i already have mzungu so that would be the obvious choice otherwise.

the only guys i can think of are I.SMith and I.Callinan both arent playing at the moment so im not very happy with the choices. ON the plus side is that darling was my 8th forward so now Didak or Petrie are my 8th forward so the guy i will bring in will be my 9th forward with richo as my 10th.

Im not sure which guy has the beter JS, it worries me that smith isnt playing at the moment as they have ahd a couple of forward ins sine he started playing. Callinan hasnt plaed yet but if he can crack the 22 he should get some games i think so im not sure.


Windigo

I'm looking at Breust......

But I'm not too keen on him either.....

You have to get it right.......

BillMurray

I brought in Smith this week despite him not being named. He's clearly rated at the club and I'm fairly sure Clarko would be making sure his knee is 100% right. I have plenty of cover once I get Mzungu next week for DPP for mid & forward link so not overly worried.  :)

Holz

Quote from: BillMurray on May 27, 2011, 07:01:15 PM
I brought in Smith this week despite him not being named. He's clearly rated at the club and I'm fairly sure Clarko would be making sure his knee is 100% right. I have plenty of cover once I get Mzungu next week for DPP for mid & forward link so not overly worried.  :)

is still smith injured or is he just not getting back into the team

Windigo

I might do the same.

Get I.SMith & have Mzungu as cover next week.

Bit pissed about Harper. Won't be back in for a long while is my guess.... ???

I had to get him, as he was the only playing rookie at that time.

A donut would have followed......

Possumo

Smith/Mzungu if you want to keep Knights, Lynch if you want to keep Darling. I guess it's a choice of keeping the player with the higher ceiling, or keeping Darling who has been really consistent. You'd have to say Lynch is probably more likely to score well/have better JS over the rest of the season based on his last two matches... that's all we ever have to base a downgrade target on though :P
Quote from: Windigo on May 27, 2011, 07:03:58 PM
I might do the same.

Get I.SMith & have Mzungu as cover next week.

Bit pissed about Harper. Won't be back in for a long while is my guess.... ???

I had to get him, as he was the only playing rookie at that time.

A donut would have followed......

Harper was being rested this week, so I doubt he'd be out for more than one week...

BillMurray

Quote from: Holzman on May 27, 2011, 07:03:07 PM
Quote from: BillMurray on May 27, 2011, 07:01:15 PM
I brought in Smith this week despite him not being named. He's clearly rated at the club and I'm fairly sure Clarko would be making sure his knee is 100% right. I have plenty of cover once I get Mzungu next week for DPP for mid & forward link so not overly worried.  :)

is still smith injured or is he just not getting back into the team

He's had a slight issue with that knee that was strapped in the St Kilda game and with what I've heard they're just being extra careful with it, given the injuries the teams had recently.

Holz

I definately can cover my forward line without smith for a while, something horrible would have to happen for me to be forced to use him at this stage, i just want him playing in 3-4 weeks and hopefully can be 200k and he can be my last double trade just beofre lockout if i have an injury free run.

Windigo

Getting I.Smith this week.

Looked fairly solid when he played.

My mate from school knows his Dad.....Might hit him up for some info.... ???

Mzungu would be my first EMG as my Fwds will be set when I go Darling>Goodes next week.

Holz

 I see the winning option in the poll is lynch and getting rid of knights whats people reason for this, surely knights is much beter than darling isnt he?

Possumo

Quote from: Holzman on May 27, 2011, 07:08:30 PM
if i have an injury free run.

I think the odds of this happening to any team are astronomical aren't they?! :(

Windigo


BillMurray

Def don't trade Knights. He's performing very well this season (apart from that one game v the dees when they got destroyed). Very pleased with him so far...

jeffbutch


Holz

Smith is playing for the box hil hawks, that means he isnt injured right?