Main Menu

Lynch

Started by Footy God, May 27, 2011, 12:59:58 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Should i bring him in?

Yes
12 (60%)
No
8 (40%)

Total Members Voted: 3

Footy God

Is he the real deal? Will he average 70+?

tappy21

To be honest noone knows. Its a gamble to get him cos theres little known about him but hes the best forward downgrade option for me. hes on the bubble and will rise in price for a few weeks yet providing he still gets picked and doesnt snap in half. thats the risk with any player tho!

LaHug

I wouldn't get him unless you were using him to make a bit of quick cash (which I wouldn't do unless I had plenty of trades to spare). He costs a fair bit more than the other rookies and he's only played two mediocre teams to get two solid scores. He also doesn't have DPP which I'm thinking is quite important at this stage. Only plus that I can see is that he'll get a good few quick price rises. But, considering I'm only bringing in rookies to keep for now (or to trade out round 23/24), I wouldn't get him.
He could prove me wrong and score like a nutter though...

FLOPITOUT1

Quote from: LaHug on May 27, 2011, 11:07:13 AM
I wouldn't get him unless you were using him to make a bit of quick cash (which I wouldn't do unless I had plenty of trades to spare). He costs a fair bit more than the other rookies and he's only played two mediocre teams to get two solid scores. He also doesn't have DPP which I'm thinking is quite important at this stage. Only plus that I can see is that he'll get a good few quick price rises. But, considering I'm only bringing in rookies to keep for now (or to trade out round 23/24), I wouldn't get him.
He could prove me wrong and score like a nutter though...
+ 1

glynman90

He could be a last cash cow which you then use to downgrade to Callinan when he returns. This is probably what I'll do which leave me with 9 or 10 trades after round 12.

Footy God

Quote from: glynman90 on May 27, 2011, 12:55:49 PM
He could be a last cash cow which you then use to downgrade to Callinan when he returns. This is probably what I'll do which leave me with 9 or 10 trades after round 12.
+1

chrisuzz

No talk on him??

Bring him in??

Krak, Richardson, Darling, Matera One of these guys ?

Cheers :)

AlexIsOnFire

I passed on him....

Key Position player, and despite 2 great scores I'd rather upgrade Tappy then downgrade him to Lynch....

This kid could be gone in a couple of weeks

He'll barely touch it against Milburn, Scarlett and Lonergan

Holz

i got in smith even though he inst playing instead of him, if i didnt have to forward downgrade this week i would get anyone beside mzungu

LaHug

Quote from: glynman90 on May 27, 2011, 12:55:49 PM
He could be a last cash cow which you then use to downgrade to Callinan when he returns. This is probably what I'll do which leave me with 9 or 10 trades after round 12.
You're giving him two weeks to make you enough cash? That sounds like wasting trades to me. Surely he won't make much cash by round 12?!

Jukes

I accidentally got Tom Lynch from the Saints...

Lol jk, I know somebody who did that.

Lynchy from GC looks good, got him in for Tappers

Footy God

Did you get him, or didnt you. Monitor his game and his score.

I have heard talk he will ruck to help Smith out, this will further help his scoring I believe. While he wmay not score 90 surely 70 is realistic.

Job securirty is good.

As you can tell, I got him. Talk about him here.

Wes Mantooth

Quote from: chrisuzz on May 27, 2011, 08:28:42 PM
No talk on him??

Bring him in??

Krak, Richardson, Darling, Matera One of these guys ?

Cheers :)

No talk on him?! There's been loads of talk.

I think there's more to him than most are giving credit. I got him.

Wes Mantooth

There are so many topics on this guy... we need to put them altogether into one super thread.

I got him too. I think he'll score 50 against geelong but should maintain 65 avg...

I think he's better than most are giving credit for.

Wes Mantooth

Quote from: LaHug on May 27, 2011, 08:52:03 PM
Quote from: glynman90 on May 27, 2011, 12:55:49 PM
He could be a last cash cow which you then use to downgrade to Callinan when he returns. This is probably what I'll do which leave me with 9 or 10 trades after round 12.
You're giving him two weeks to make you enough cash? That sounds like wasting trades to me. Surely he won't make much cash by round 12?!

+1 thats crazy talk... callinan is still a while off yet though, plus his 2 weeks to prove himself even though he is 80K. craig ditches new people with ease...even if they are mature age