The official inaugural who to start thread...

[elephants]

Just thought we would compile all the who to start threads into one.

Please just name your problem and attempt to help others

Cheers LE

I'll start off

Puopolo vs bulldogs

Or

Lower vs saints

[LEV]

i would say lower, he is more than capable.

Ok, my turn, which jack should i start?

jack riewoldt or jack darling?

[Chelskiman]

I'd go JRoo.  Should carve it up against a poor Port defence.  Darling will be up against the likes of Harry O or Maxwell who are quality defenders.

Who should I start, Ben Jacobs or Nick Lower?

[hally25547]

I'd go JRoo.  Should carve it up against a poor Port defence.  Darling will be up against the likes of Harry O or Maxwell who are quality defenders.

Who should I start, Ben Jacobs or Nick Lower?

Lower because last weeks game would have made harvey realise that he is a gun.

Smith or Petrie (I have the DPP link)

[LEV]

Smith or Petrie (I have the DPP link)

thats a tough one. very very tough.  So ill leave it to someone else who knows what they're on about (bet you just read this and thought "dammit")

[hally25547]

Smith or Petrie (I have the DPP link)

thats a tough one. very very tough.  So ill leave it to someone else who knows what they're on about (bet you just read this and thought "dammit")

haha yep

[Fenno]

Smith or Petrie would depend on who would come into the Forward line for Petrie if you think that player can score better than Smith go Petrie otherwise go Smith.

[elephants]

Riewoldt of the jacks

Jacobs over lower. Primes will play him in mids after a very strong second half in the midfield.

Smith coming off a week off

Going well guys!

[hally25547]

Smith or Petrie would depend on who would come into the Forward line for Petrie if you think that player can score better than Smith go Petrie otherwise go Smith.

it depends on my trades but at this stage it would be isaac smith.

[Descent]

not that he's playing this week, but im seriously considering playing zac smith over paddy ryder in the future

ryder has been lumbering around lazily, dropping easy marks... looks very uninterested with whats going on

is playing smith a stupid idea?

[elephants]

Personally i don't see the point in having Ryder on your bench. If you do start smithy (not an all bad idea) downgrade Ryder to max Bailey for a sugarload of dough and a playing third ruckmen :)

[dale93]

Which 2 to start out of Swallow, Harris, Conca and Libba?

[Chelskiman]

Libba and Conca.  Harris and Swallow are going to get slaughtered against Geelong.

[Memphistopheles]

Smith or Petrie (I have the DPP link)

thats a tough one. very very tough.  So ill leave it to someone else who knows what they're on about (bet you just read this and thought "dammit")

haha yep

Geelong were talking about resting Ottens. If so Smith should dominate :P

Stanley or Jacobs in defence?

[BillMurray]

I'm playing Jacobs over Stanley. Danny will get smoked against cats midfield