Chappy and Lynch

Started by love4thegame, May 23, 2011, 03:11:43 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

What would you do?

Tapscott OUT Lynch IN
16 (48.5%)
Tapscott OUT Rookie IN Darling OUT Chapman IN
16 (48.5%)
Darling OUT Lynch IN
1 (3%)
Other (List Below)
0 (0%)

Total Members Voted: 2

TMurphBROWNLOW

was going to wait a week with chappy but he's playing GC meaning he'll tear it up and probably drop say 4k if he hits 110+ ? darling would only make 4-5k so a gain of 10k is not worth an extra 50-60 points!

Windigo

#16
If you downgrade to Lynch via a Tappy trade. You make chump change.

Why not get Mzungu next week who is cheaper with MPP?

This only my opinion. I could do it. But I want to keep Darling as perma bench cover. Better to risk it and get rid of Darling for Chappy next week?

Can't be done. Not getting T.Lynch.

love4thegame

Quote from: TMurphBROWNLOW on May 23, 2011, 07:51:02 PM
was going to wait a week with chappy but he's playing GC meaning he'll tear it up and probably drop say 4k if he hits 110+ ? darling would only make 4-5k so a gain of 10k is not worth an extra 50-60 points!
The problem is for the the only way I can get chappy this week is trading matera for a nothing player and darling for chappy or I can go tappy for lynch this week then slot in chappy next week

TMurphBROWNLOW

i'm going to have to miss out on lynch, i want smith for the dpp much more than lynch's great scoring. isaac seems like a capable scorer anyway :)

Windigo

What about getting  Mzungu & Smith this week?

Double downgrade anyone?

Then Darling>Chappy plus some $$$ left over..... :)

TMurphBROWNLOW

wait a week for mzungu :)

Windigo

I'll get I.Smith if named and wait on Tendai then snaffle him up, bye Matera.

Then Darling>Chapman.  8)

How many Hawks is to many?

Suckling, Franklin, Puopolo, Bailey & I.Smith?

Also, Smith should play, was he dropped or was he out with "General Softness."

love4thegame

Quote from: Windigo on May 23, 2011, 08:22:31 PM
What about getting  Mzungu & Smith this week?

Double downgrade anyone?

Then Darling>Chappy plus some $$$ left over..... :)
I like the idea! I'd go tapscott out lynch in a. Smith out I. Smith in maybe then darling too chappy next week

Windigo

#23
Quotelike the idea! I'd go tapscott out lynch in a. Smith out I. Smith in maybe then darling too chappy next week

Okay, might do.....Quickly does some calculations....

I would have $ 201,400 to spend next week.

Right now Darling is $ 273,400 + $ 201,400

Would give me $ 474,800 to burn.....

Chappy will fall to about $ 395,000 and then next week I could possibly get Deledio or easily Enright.

I could get Goodes and it would be assured that I would get Deledio for Stanley......

Thanks Luv4thegame, really got me thinking....

What do you think????

Fwds: Franklin, Sylvia, N.Riewoldt, S.Johnson, Goodes/Chapman, Higgins & Petrie           Lynch, I.Smith & Harper

Backs: Goddard, Adcock, Heppell, Gibbs, Suckling, Deledio/Enright & Jacobs         Puopolo, Lower & Coad

love4thegame

Getting goodes depends on how many Richmond and Brisbane players you have because of the multi bye in round 19!

Windigo

Quoteetting goodes depends on how many Richmond and Brisbane players you have because of the multi bye in round 19!

At the moment.

Swans players=0
Tigers players=0
Lions players=3 (Adcock, Redden & Bewick)

bundyboy

lynch looks great this early, but honestly don't expect his scores to stay that high, and only bench cover no matter what...

chappy looks almost cheapest he is going to be...so time to jump on board....


for me, can't get lynch as i'm jumping on jacobs - and mnguzu next week is my downgrade plan...

Bill Manspeaker

bundyboy you're on the money.

at first Lynch was a dead set lock for me but with more thought put into it i'm thinking Swallow -> Jacobs, Tapscott -> Chapman. does that sound alright?

love4thegame

Quote from: brad on May 23, 2011, 11:53:50 PM
bundyboy you're on the money.

at first Lynch was a dead set lock for me but with more thought put into it i'm thinking Swallow -> Jacobs, Tapscott -> Chapman. does that sound alright?
If you can do it , go for it!
I'm thinking maybe just tapscott for lynch this week then a.smith out evans in darling out chappy in. Lynch could be great bench cover but would that be a wasted trade?
Having a look I could go Matera out May IN tapscott out chappy In or tapscott out smith/Breust in chappy in, would love if smith got named