Gaz or j.selwood??

Started by chatters24, May 23, 2011, 08:20:50 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Who's the better pick up??

G.Ablett
2 (8.3%)
J.Selwood
21 (87.5%)
Other
1 (4.2%)

Total Members Voted: 3

chatters24

G'day guys.

I need a bit of help on a decision for my final premium midfielders spot. Right now I have swan, pendles, Boyd, montagnaAnd mundy. I'm looking at filling my last spot with either Gaz or Joel selwood. The advantage with Gaz is his price and that he has no more byes, however disadvantage is that his scores other his 156 in his last game and one other has all been in the 80s. Selwoon on the other hand still has a bye to come but is a lot more more of a consistent scorer this yr compared to Gaz. I can afford any midfielder.

What's your thoughts??

Chopps

#1
Selwood, My mids are exactly the same I was always going to get gaz rd 10 last week I got mundy got selwood the week. Before

antonc

I would go jelwood (have him myself) and prob go ablett this week

Ziplock

I would be definitely going selwood unless you're ridiculously strapped for cash.

LaHug

Where are you ranked? If you have eyes on the prize, may have to go Ablett for uniqueness (and although lots have him, none of the top contenders seem to).
If you're just playing for fun or eliminator or league maybe (if you think you can win finals round 1 or have a trade up your sleeve if you need to), then get Selwood for his big and consistent scoring.

chatters24

Quote from: LaHug on May 23, 2011, 09:56:25 AM
Where are you ranked? If you have eyes on the prize, may have to go Ablett for uniqueness (and although lots have him, none of the top contenders seem to).
If you're just playing for fun or eliminator or league maybe (if you think you can win finals round 1 or have a trade up your sleeve if you need to), then get Selwood for his big and consistent scoring.

I'm ranked 5,500ish which is decent. Would like to push on to top 2000 by seasons end. Also in champs and elite league on here so have to remain competitive. I think I really should go selwood. I think some of the kids that Gaz has around him at the moment will fade towards the end of the season, and with that even more pressure on him from opposition clubs. I think his body can be a little fragile at times and he could get a little banged up towards the end.

hardnut

sounds like your decided Chaser, Jelwood is the better pick in a straight h2h, just keep a trade up your sleeve for finals (and maybe another one tog et him back in!)

chatters24

Thanks for the feedback boys! (and any girls who may have responded)

PowerBug

Other is a DT premium. He is a much better pick up than Gary or Joel.